Irita Kazuo, Kawashima Yasuo, Morita Kiyoshi, Tsuzaki Koichi, Seo Norimasa, Iwao Yasuhide, Obara Hidefumi
Department of Anesthesiology and Critical Care Medicine, Graduate School of Medical Sciences, Kyushu University, Fukuoka 812-8582.
Masui. 2003 Mar;52(3):304-19.
In Japan, the incidence of cardiac morbidity among patients with ischemic heart diseases has been reported to be 13.2-16.4%, and that of perioperative myocardial infarction in these patients about 1%. We investigated the perioperative morbidity and mortality due to coronary ischemia by using data from an annual survey concerning anesthesia-related critical incidents, conducted by the Committee on Operating Room Safety, Japanese Society of Anesthesiologists. In this survey, coronary ischemia was divided into intraoperative pathological events (coronary ischemia as intraoperative event) and preoperative complication (coronary ischemia as preoperative complication). The former consists of coronary ischemia which developed in patients without preoperative diagnosis of ischemic heart diseases or which was induced by surgical and/or anesthetic procedures. The latter was coronary ischemia developed in patients with preoperative diagnosis of ischemic heart diseases. From January 1, 1999, to December 31, 2001, 3,020,021 patients were registered from certified training hospitals of Japanese Society of the Anesthesiologists in the survey. Among them 1,918 episodes of intraoperative cardiac arrest and 2,054 deaths (within 7th postoperative days) were reported. Of these 7.5% and 6.3% of cardiac arrests were due to coronary ischemia as intraoperative event and as preoperative complication, respectively. Death was due to coronary ischemia as intraoperative event in 4.0% and as preoperative complication in 5.1%. The occurrence of critical incidents (cardiac arrest and the other life-threatening events) due to both types of coronary ischemia depended on ASA-PS. The percentage of coronary ischemia as preoperative complication was higher in emergency patients than in elective patients. The percentage of coronary ischemia as intraoperative event was almost the same between emergency and elective patients. Both types of coronary ischemia developed most frequently in cardiac/aortic surgeries, followed by thoracotomy with or without laparotomy. The number of critical incidents due to coronary ischemia as preoperative complication was the largest in emergency cardiac/aortic surgeries, followed by elective non-cardiac surgeries. The number of critical incidents due to coronary ischemia as intraoperative event was the largest in elective non-cardiac, especially open abdominal, surgeries in patients with ASA-PS 1(E) + 2(E). Among the patients with ASA-PS 1(E) + 2(E) who underwent non-cardiac surgeries 13.9% of deaths were due to coronary ischemia as preoperative complication and 12.5% as intraoperative event. It should be noted that many critical incidents due to coronary ischemia as intraoperative event during laparotomy developed in patients anesthetized by inhalation anesthesia combined with epidural, spinal or conduction block. Prognosis of cardiac arrest due to coronary ischemia as preoperative complication was the worst: 47.1% of these patients died. The best prognosis was found in critical incidents other than cardiac arrest due to coronary ischemia as intraoperative event with mortality of 12.3%. The results show that quality improvement from the standpoint of intraoperative coronary ischemia is required.
据报道,在日本,缺血性心脏病患者中心脏病发病率为13.2% - 16.4%,这些患者围手术期心肌梗死发生率约为1%。我们利用日本麻醉医师协会手术室安全委员会开展的一项有关麻醉相关严重事件的年度调查数据,对冠状动脉缺血导致的围手术期发病率和死亡率进行了调查。在这项调查中,冠状动脉缺血被分为术中病理事件(术中发生的冠状动脉缺血事件)和术前并发症(术前发生的冠状动脉缺血并发症)。前者包括术前未诊断为缺血性心脏病的患者发生的冠状动脉缺血,或由手术和/或麻醉操作诱发的冠状动脉缺血。后者是术前已诊断为缺血性心脏病的患者发生的冠状动脉缺血。从1999年1月1日至2001年12月31日,日本麻醉医师协会认证培训医院登记了3020021例患者参与该调查。其中报告了1918例术中心脏骤停和2054例死亡(术后7天内)。在这些病例中,分别有7.5%和6.3%的心脏骤停是由术中冠状动脉缺血事件和术前冠状动脉缺血并发症导致的。因术中冠状动脉缺血事件导致的死亡占4.0%,因术前冠状动脉缺血并发症导致的死亡占5.1%。两种类型冠状动脉缺血导致的严重事件(心脏骤停和其他危及生命的事件)的发生取决于美国麻醉医师协会身体状况分级(ASA - PS)。术前冠状动脉缺血并发症在急诊患者中的比例高于择期手术患者。术中冠状动脉缺血事件在急诊和择期患者中的比例几乎相同。两种类型的冠状动脉缺血最常发生于心脏/主动脉手术,其次是开胸手术(无论是否联合剖腹手术)。术前冠状动脉缺血并发症导致的严重事件数量在急诊心脏/主动脉手术中最多,其次是择期非心脏手术。术中冠状动脉缺血事件导致的严重事件数量在择期非心脏手术中最多,尤其是ASA - PS 1(E) + 2(E)患者的开腹手术。在接受非心脏手术的ASA - PS 1(E) + 2(E)患者中,13.9%的死亡是由术前冠状动脉缺血并发症导致的,12.5%是由术中冠状动脉缺血事件导致的。需要注意的是,在开腹手术期间,许多因术中冠状动脉缺血事件导致的严重事件发生在接受吸入麻醉联合硬膜外、脊髓或传导阻滞麻醉的患者中。术前冠状动脉缺血并发症导致的心脏骤停预后最差:这些患者中有47.1%死亡。术中冠状动脉缺血事件导致的非心脏骤停严重事件预后最好,死亡率为12.3%。结果表明,需要从术中冠状动脉缺血的角度改善医疗质量。