Staib L, Link K H, Henne-Bruns D
Abteilung für Viszeral- und Transplantationschirurgie, Chirurgische Universitätsklinik Ulm, Steinhövelstrasse 9, 89075 Ulm.
Kongressbd Dtsch Ges Chir Kongr. 2002;119:142-5.
Based on preclinical and clinical studies, in this German three-arm adjuvant multicenter trial the FOGT (Forschungsgruppe Onkologie Gastrointestinale Tumoren) studied whether one of the 5-FU modulations with either folinic acid(FA) or Interferon alpha-2a (IFNa) is superior to the recommended standard of adjuvant treatment in R0-resected colon cancer, 5-fluorouracil (5-FU) plus levamisole (LEV) for 12 months, in terms of overall survival rates.
PATIENTS/METHODS: From 7/92 to 10/99 813 patients with resected colon cancer stage II (only T4N0M0, 63 pts.) and stage III (750 pts.) were randomized into three treatment groups and stratified according to N-stage and participating centers (64 hospitals). The patients received a postoperative loading course with 5-FU [450 mg/m2 d1-5 (arms A and C)] or 5-FU [450 mg/m2 plus folinic acid (Rescuvolin, medac, Hamburg, Germany), 200 mg/m2 d1-5 (arm B)]. After completion of the first chemotherapy cycle LEV was administered orally at 150 mg/d d1-3, every 2 weeks. After a 4-week chemotherapy-free interval the treatment was continued weekly for up to 52 weeks. The standard group, arm A (279 pts.) was treated with 5-FU i.v. (450 mg/m2 at d 1, q 1 w) plus LEV. 5-FU plus LEV was modulated in arm B (283 pts.) with FA (200 mg/m2 d1, q 1 w), and in arm C (251 pts.) with IFNa at 6 million units 3x/week, q 1 w. Chemotherapy doses were adjusted to toxicity if toxic events > WHO 2 occurred. The patients were followed-up to determine relapse rates and--patterns and survival. Survival rates were calculated according to Kaplan-Meier, and treatment costs and immune effects were analysed.
Toxic event(s) > WHO2, mainly leukopenia, diarrhea and nausea, occurred in 113 pts. (14%), in arms A (8%), B (13%) and C (32%). Discontinuance rates were 28% (all), 29% (A), 21% (B), 34% (C), but 80% of patients received > or = 6 months treatment. Overall relapse rates were 27% (all), 30% (A), 24% (B) and 28% (C). Tumors relapsed either locally (2% each) or distant (A: 22%, B: 20%, C: 22%). 4-year overall survival rates in arms A, B and C were 66%, 77%, 66%, respectively. The 4-year survival rate in arm B was significantly superior to arms A and C (p < 0.02, log-rank). There were no signs of a superior immune function in either treatment arm (skin test, proliferation, cytotoxicity, flow cytometry). Treatment costs per patient were 2,500 [symbol: see text](arm A), 3,500 [symbol: see text](arm B) or 10,850 [symbol: see text](arm C), respectively.
Adjuvant therapy with 5-FU plus FA plus LEV for 12 months is superior to the recommended standard (5-FU + LEV, 12 m). IFNa-modulation of 5-FU (plus LEV) adds toxicity and high treatment costs without therapeutic benefit.
基于临床前和临床研究,在这项德国三臂辅助多中心试验中,胃肠道肿瘤研究小组(FOGT)研究了在R0切除的结肠癌中,用亚叶酸(FA)或干扰素α-2a(IFNa)进行的5-氟尿嘧啶(5-FU)调节之一在总生存率方面是否优于推荐的辅助治疗标准,即5-氟尿嘧啶(5-FU)加左旋咪唑(LEV)治疗12个月。
患者/方法:从1992年7月至1999年10月,813例II期(仅T4N0M0,63例)和III期(750例)结肠癌切除患者被随机分为三个治疗组,并根据N分期和参与中心(64家医院)进行分层。患者接受5-FU的术后负荷疗程[450mg/m² d1-5(A组和C组)]或5-FU[450mg/m²加亚叶酸(德国汉堡medac公司的Rescuvolin),200mg/m² d1-5(B组)]。在第一个化疗周期完成后,LEV以150mg/d d1-3口服给药,每2周一次。在4周的无化疗间隔期后,治疗每周持续进行,最长52周。标准组A组(279例)接受5-FU静脉注射(450mg/m²在d1,每1周一次)加LEV治疗。5-FU加LEV在B组(283例)中用FA(200mg/m² d1,每1周一次)进行调节,在C组(251例)中用IFNa 600万单位每周3次,每1周一次进行调节。如果发生>WHO 2级的毒性事件,则调整化疗剂量。对患者进行随访以确定复发率、复发模式和生存率。根据Kaplan-Meier法计算生存率,并分析治疗成本和免疫效应。
WHO2级的毒性事件,主要是白细胞减少、腹泻和恶心,发生在113例患者中(14%),A组(8%)、B组(13%)和C组(32%)。停药率分别为28%(总体)、29%(A组)、21%(B组)、34%(C组),但80%的患者接受了≥6个月的治疗。总体复发率分别为27%(总体)、30%(A组)、24%(B组)和28%(C组)。肿瘤复发部位为局部(每组2%)或远处(A组:22%,B组:20%,C组:22%)。A组、B组和C组的4年总生存率分别为66%、77%、66%。B组的4年生存率显著优于A组和C组(p<0.02,对数秩检验)。在任何一个治疗组中均未发现免疫功能增强的迹象(皮肤试验、增殖、细胞毒性、流式细胞术)。每位患者的治疗成本分别为2500[符号:见原文](A组)、3500[符号:见原文](B组)或10850[符号:见原文](C组)。
5-FU加FA加LEV辅助治疗12个月优于推荐标准(5-FU+LEV,12个月)。5-FU(加LEV)的IFNa调节增加了毒性和高治疗成本,且无治疗益处。