Crutcher Rodney A, Banner Sandra R, Szafran Olga, Watanabe Mamoru
Department of Family Medicine, University of Calgary, Calgary, Alta.
CMAJ. 2003 Apr 29;168(9):1119-23.
International medical graduates are an important component of the Canadian physician workforce. For most international medical graduates, the principal route to obtaining a residency position in Canada is to apply through the second iteration of the Canadian Resident Matching Service (CaRMS) match. In order to help inform the work toward integrating unlicensed international medical graduates into Canada's health professional workforce, our objectives were to describe the demographic and educational characteristics of international medical graduate CaRMS applicants and identify their preferred clinical disciplines and practice locations.
A 37-item Web-based questionnaire survey was offered to all 659 international medical graduate second-iteration CaRMS 2002 applicants. We collected data on their demographic and educational background and preferred clinical discipline and practice location. Up to 2 follow-up email reminders were sent to nonrespondents.
The survey response rate was 70.3% (463/659). Of the respondents, 71.9% had obtained their medical degree in Asia, the Middle East or Eastern Europe: 36.5% had graduated with a medical degree since 1994, and 17.3% since 1997. Most respondents (74.3%) were aged between 30 and 44 years. More than half (54.6%) had completed their medical education in English. Most (69.3%) had done postgraduate training outside Canada. Before coming to Canada, 42.8% had practised medicine for 1-5 years and 45.6% had practised for 6-20 years. The top 5 choices of clinical discipline in Canada were family medicine/general practice (45.6%), internal medicine (14.9%), surgery (7.3%), obstetrics/gynecology (6.7%) and pediatrics (4.8%). Of those who resided in the 4 Western provinces or Nova Scotia, between 76.8% and 86.7% preferred to stay in their own province, and 60%, 51.4% and 37% of those who resided in Newfoundland, Ontario or Quebec respectively preferred to practise in their own province.
Second-iteration international medical graduate CaRMS applicants are a heterogeneous group of physicians, some with substantial medical training and experience and others at an earlier stage of their medical career.
国际医学毕业生是加拿大医师队伍的重要组成部分。对于大多数国际医学毕业生来说,在加拿大获得住院医师职位的主要途径是通过加拿大住院医师匹配服务(CaRMS)第二轮匹配申请。为了有助于为将无执照的国际医学毕业生融入加拿大卫生专业队伍的工作提供信息,我们的目标是描述国际医学毕业生CaRMS申请人的人口统计学和教育特征,并确定他们首选的临床学科和执业地点。
向2002年CaRMS第二轮的所有659名国际医学毕业生申请人提供了一份包含37个项目的基于网络的问卷调查。我们收集了他们的人口统计学和教育背景以及首选的临床学科和执业地点的数据。向未回复者发送了最多2次后续电子邮件提醒。
调查回复率为70.3%(463/659)。在受访者中,71.9%在亚洲、中东或东欧获得医学学位;36.5%自1994年以来获得医学学位,17.3%自1997年以来获得医学学位。大多数受访者(74.3%)年龄在30至44岁之间。超过一半(54.6%)的人用英语完成了医学教育。大多数(69.3%)在加拿大境外接受过研究生培训。来加拿大之前,42.8%的人有1至5年的行医经历,45.6%的人有6至20年的行医经历。在加拿大,临床学科的前5大选择是家庭医学/全科医学(45.6%)、内科(14.9%)、外科(7.3%)、妇产科(6.7%)和儿科(4.8%)。居住在4个西部省份或新斯科舍省的人中,76.8%至86.7%的人更愿意留在自己所在的省份,而居住在纽芬兰、安大略或魁北克的人中,分别有60%、51.4%和37%的人更愿意在自己所在的省份执业。
CaRMS第二轮国际医学毕业生申请人是一个异质的医师群体,一些人有丰富的医学培训和经验,另一些人则处于医学职业生涯的早期阶段。