Kimura Hiroshi, Aso Shin, Watanabe Yukio
Department of Otolaryngology, Faculty of Medicine, Toyama Medical and Pharmaceutical University, Toyama City, Japan.
Acta Otolaryngol. 2003 Apr;123(3):388-95. doi: 10.1080/0036554021000028079.
To investigate whether electrocochleography (ECochG) and glycerol and furosemide tests could predict progression from atypical to definite Ménière's disease (MD).
ECochG and glycerol and furosemide tests were performed in 1569 patients with various cochleovestibular diseases, including definite MD, atypical MD, syphilitic labyrinthitis, delayed endolymphatic hydrops, sudden hearing loss, cochleovestibulopathy and sensorineural hearing loss. Patients with atypical MD were divided into five categories based on their symptoms.
A total of 115/118 patients (97%) with definite MD who underwent all 3 tests showed a positive result in at least 1 test. Ninety-nine patients who did not satisfy the diagnostic criteria of definite MD but had vertigo and/or hearing loss at the first visit subsequently progressed to definite MD. It was retrospectively found that 92% of patients showed at least 1 positive finding in these 3 tests at the initial stage. In those patients who showed a negative test result in either ECochG or the glycerol test, the possibility of progression to definite MD was low.
The combination of ECochG and the glycerol and furosemide tests was helpful in diagnosing endolymphatic hydrops (ELH). ECochG and the glycerol test were effective tools for predicting the progression to definite MD in patients with atypical MD, sudden hearing loss and other cochleovestibular diseases. Our test results also indicated that the pathological state of atypical MD included both non-ELH and ELH.
探讨耳蜗电图(ECochG)、甘油试验和速尿试验能否预测非典型梅尼埃病(MD)向典型MD的进展。
对1569例患有各种耳蜗前庭疾病的患者进行了ECochG、甘油试验和速尿试验,这些疾病包括典型MD、非典型MD、梅毒性迷路炎、迟发性内淋巴积水、突发性听力损失、耳蜗前庭病和感音神经性听力损失。非典型MD患者根据其症状分为五类。
118例接受了所有三项检查的典型MD患者中,共有115例(97%)至少有一项检查结果呈阳性。99例不符合典型MD诊断标准但首次就诊时有眩晕和/或听力损失的患者随后进展为典型MD。回顾性发现,92%的患者在初始阶段这三项检查中至少有一项阳性结果。在ECochG或甘油试验中检查结果为阴性的患者中,进展为典型MD的可能性较低。
ECochG与甘油试验和速尿试验相结合有助于诊断内淋巴积水(ELH)。ECochG和甘油试验是预测非典型MD、突发性听力损失和其他耳蜗前庭疾病患者进展为典型MD的有效工具。我们的检查结果还表明,非典型MD的病理状态包括非ELH和ELH。