Vázquez María Luisa, da Silva Maria Rejane Ferreira, Campos Eliane Siqueira, Arruda Ilma Kruze Grande de, Diniz Alcides da Silva, Veras Ida Leite, Pereira Ana Paula Campos
CHC Consultoria i Gestió, Barcelona, España.
Cad Saude Publica. 2003 Mar-Apr;19(2):579-91. doi: 10.1590/s0102-311x2003000200025. Epub 2003 May 15.
Social participation in management of the health care system at different levels of government is one of the key policies promoted by the Unified National Health System (SUS) in Brazil. As with any new policy, success hinges on several factors such as stakeholders' interests and opinions, which have not always been considered in the past. This paper analyzes the underlying concepts of two groups of stakeholders with respect to social participation in health and the potential influence of these concepts on the effectiveness of policy implementation. A case study of two municipalities in Northeast Brazil was conducted using a combination of qualitative and quantitative social science research methods. Health services users and community leaders were interviewed. Various concepts were found in which the participatory approach to health policies was only partially reflected. Likely influences on stakeholders' concepts of social participation in health are the evolution of the broader Brazilian social context and the traditional performance of health services. Particular attention should be paid to stakeholders' opinions and concepts if policy effectiveness is to be improved.
在巴西,不同政府层面的社会参与医疗保健系统管理是统一国家卫生系统(SUS)推行的关键政策之一。与任何新政策一样,成功取决于多个因素,如利益相关者的利益和意见,而这些因素在过去并不总是得到考虑。本文分析了两组利益相关者在社会参与卫生方面的潜在概念,以及这些概念对政策实施有效性的潜在影响。采用定性和定量社会科学研究方法相结合的方式,对巴西东北部的两个城市进行了案例研究。对卫生服务使用者和社区领袖进行了访谈。发现了各种概念,其中卫生政策的参与式方法仅得到部分体现。巴西更广泛社会背景的演变以及卫生服务的传统表现可能会影响利益相关者对社会参与卫生的概念。如果要提高政策有效性,应特别关注利益相关者的意见和概念。