Matsudaira Kagari, Nakagawa Hiroshi, Wittkampf Fred H M, Yamanashi William S, Imai Shinobu, Pitha Jan V, Lazzara Ralph, Jackman Warren M
Cardiac Arrhythmia Research Institute, Department of Medicine University of Oklahoma Health Sciences Center, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma 73104, USA.
Pacing Clin Electrophysiol. 2003 May;26(5):1227-37. doi: 10.1046/j.1460-9592.2003.t01-1-00173.x.
The authors hypothesized that during RF ablation, the electrode to tissue interface temperature may significantly exceed electrode temperature in the presence of cooling blood flow and produce thrombus. In 12 anesthetized dogs, the skin over the thigh muscle was incised and raised to form a cradle that was superfused with heparinized canine blood (ACT > 350 s) at 37 degrees C. A 7 Fr, 4-mm or 8-mm ablation electrode containing a thermocouple was held perpendicular to the thigh muscle at 10-g contact weight. Interface temperature was measured at opposite sides of the electrode using tiny optical probes. RF applications (n = 157) were delivered at an electrode temperature of 45 degrees C, 55 degrees C, 65 degrees C, and 75 degrees C for 60 seconds, with or without pulsatile blood flow (150 mL/min). Without blood flow, the interface temperature was similar to the electrode temperature. With blood flow, the interface temperature (side opposite blood flow) was up to 36 degrees C and 57 degrees C higher than the electrode temperature using the 4- and 8-mm electrodes, respectively. After each RF, the cradle was emptied and the electrode and interface were examined. Thrombus developed without impedance rise at an interface temperature as low as 73 degrees C without blood flow and 80 degrees C with blood flow (11/16 RFs at 65 degrees C electrode temperature using 4 mm and 13/13 RFs at an electrode temperature of 55 degrees C using an 8-mm electrode with blood flow). With blood flow, interface temperature markedly exceeded the electrode temperature and the difference was greater with an 8-mm electrode (due to greater electrode cooling). In the presence of blood flow, thrombus occurred without an impedance rise at an electrode temperature as low as 65 degrees C with a 4-mm electrode and 55 degrees C with an 8-mm electrode.
作者们推测,在射频消融过程中,在存在冷却血流的情况下,电极与组织界面的温度可能会显著超过电极温度,并产生血栓。在12只麻醉犬中,切开大腿肌肉上方的皮肤并掀起形成一个支架,用37℃的肝素化犬血(活化凝血时间>350秒)对其进行灌注。将一个装有热电偶的7F、4mm或8mm消融电极以10g的接触重量垂直于大腿肌肉放置。使用微型光学探头在电极的相对两侧测量界面温度。在电极温度为45℃、55℃、65℃和75℃的情况下进行射频应用(n = 157),持续60秒,有无搏动性血流(150 mL/分钟)。无血流时,界面温度与电极温度相似。有血流时,使用4mm和8mm电极时,界面温度(血流相反侧)分别比电极温度高出36℃和57℃。每次射频后,排空支架并检查电极和界面。在无血流时,界面温度低至73℃,有血流时低至80℃(使用4mm电极在电极温度为65℃时11/16次射频、使用8mm电极在电极温度为55℃且有血流时13/13次射频),在无阻抗升高的情况下形成血栓。有血流时,界面温度明显超过电极温度,且使用8mm电极时差异更大(由于电极冷却更强)。有血流时,使用4mm电极在电极温度低至65℃、使用8mm电极在电极温度低至55℃时,在无阻抗升高的情况下发生血栓。