Welke Karl F, BootsMiller Bonnie J, McCoy Kimberly D, Vaughn Thomas E, Ward Marcia M, Flach Stephen D, Peloso Paul M, Sorofman Bernard A, Tripp-Reimer Toni, Doebbeling Bradley N
Division of Cardiothoracic Surgery, The University of Iowa Hospitals and Clinics, Iowa City, Iowa, USA.
Am J Med Qual. 2003 May-Jun;18(3):122-7. doi: 10.1177/106286060301800306.
Provider knowledge is a potential barrier to adherence to clinical guidelines. The purpose of this study is to assess the impact of organizational, provider, and guideline factors on provider knowledge of a congestive heart failure (CHF) clinical practice guideline (CPG) in the Veterans Health Administration (VHA) health care system. We developed a survey to investigate institution-level factors influencing the effectiveness of guideline implementation, including characteristics of the guideline, providers, hospital culture and structure, and regional network. Survey participants were quality managers, primary care administrators, and other individuals involved in primary care CPG implementation at 143 VHA hospitals with ambulatory care clinics. Potential explanatory variables were grouped into 11 factors. Multivariate regression models assessed the association between these factors and reported levels of provider knowledge regarding the CHF guideline at the hospital level. Two hundred forty surveys from 126 of 143 (88%) VHA hospitals were returned. Provider knowledge of the CHF guideline was estimated as "great" or "very great" by 58% of respondents. Three predictor factors (dissemination approaches, use of technology in guideline implementation, and hospital culture) were independently associated (P < or = .05) with provider knowledge. Specific variables within these categories that were related to greater knowledge included physician belief that guidelines were applicable to their practice, distribution of guideline summaries, use of guideline storyboards in clinic areas, the use of technology (eg, electronic patient records) in CPG implementation, and establishment of implementation checkpoints and deadlines. Provider knowledge of guidelines is affected by factors at various organizational levels: dissemination approaches, use of technology, and hospital culture. Guideline implementation efforts that target multiple organizational levels may increase provider knowledge.
提供者的知识是遵循临床指南的一个潜在障碍。本研究的目的是评估组织、提供者和指南因素对退伍军人健康管理局(VHA)医疗保健系统中充血性心力衰竭(CHF)临床实践指南(CPG)提供者知识的影响。我们开展了一项调查,以研究影响指南实施效果的机构层面因素,包括指南、提供者、医院文化和结构以及区域网络的特征。调查参与者为143家设有门诊诊所的VHA医院中参与初级保健CPG实施的质量管理人员、初级保健管理人员及其他人员。潜在解释变量被分为11个因素。多变量回归模型评估了这些因素与医院层面报告的提供者关于CHF指南的知识水平之间的关联。143家VHA医院中的126家(88%)返回了240份调查问卷。58%的受访者将提供者对CHF指南的知识评为“很好”或“非常好”。三个预测因素(传播方法、指南实施中的技术应用和医院文化)与提供者知识独立相关(P≤0.05)。这些类别中与更多知识相关的具体变量包括医生认为指南适用于其临床实践、指南摘要的分发、在临床区域使用指南情节串联图板、在CPG实施中使用技术(如电子病历)以及设立实施检查点和期限。提供者对指南的知识受到不同组织层面因素的影响:传播方法、技术应用和医院文化。针对多个组织层面的指南实施工作可能会增加提供者的知识。