Hanley Nick, Schläpfer Felix, Spurgeon James
Department of Economics, University of Glasgow, Adam Smith Building, G12 8RT, Scotland, Glasgow, UK. n.d
J Environ Manage. 2003 Jul;68(3):297-304. doi: 10.1016/s0301-4797(03)00084-7.
One of the main problems in using environmental cost-benefit analysis is deciding on the relevant population: whose benefits should we count? This is important since aggregate benefits depend on both per-person benefit and the number of beneficiaries. Yet this latter term is often hard to evaluate. Distance-decay functions are one way of addressing this problem. In this paper, we present estimates of distance-decay functions for a particular environmental improvement, namely a reduction in low flow problems on the River Mimram in Southern England. We do this both for users and non-users, in the context of a contingent valuation study of the benefits of improving low flow conditions. We test whether distance-decay effects for mean Willingness to Pay are stronger for a single environmental good (the River Mimram, in this case) than for a more inclusive set (here, all rivers in Thames region which suffer from low flow problems). Finally, we explore the impact on part-whole bias, in terms of the relationship between WTP for an individual site and WTP for a more inclusive group of sites, of allowing for distance-decay effects.
我们应该计算谁的收益?这很重要,因为总收益取决于人均收益和受益人数。然而,后一个术语往往很难评估。距离衰减函数是解决这个问题的一种方法。在本文中,我们给出了特定环境改善的距离衰减函数估计值,即减少英格兰南部米姆拉姆河的低流量问题。我们在对改善低流量条件的效益进行的条件价值评估研究的背景下,对使用者和非使用者都进行了这样的估计。我们测试对于单一环境物品(在这种情况下是米姆拉姆河),平均支付意愿的距离衰减效应是否比对更具包容性的集合(这里是泰晤士地区所有存在低流量问题的河流)更强。最后,我们探讨了考虑距离衰减效应后,个体地点的支付意愿与更具包容性的地点组的支付意愿之间的关系对部分 - 整体偏差的影响。