Massin P, Astoin E, Lavaste F
Service de Chirurgie Orthopédique, CHU Angers, 4, rue Larrey, 49033 Angers Cedex 01. PhMassin@chu-angers
Rev Chir Orthop Reparatrice Appar Mot. 2003 Apr;89(2):134-43.
The combined effects of proximal canal filling and stem-cement surface characteristics on stresses in the cement and bone in femoral hip arthrosplasty were investigated by finite element analysis.
Our finite element study of a femoral implant fitted with a stainless steel stem was based on a set of 4 models with decreasing metaphyseal fill, designed to simulate loading before the occurrence of any deterioration in the cement-bone interface. Thus, the cement was represented fully bonded to the bone. The implant-cement interface was modeling in the bonded and debonded states. First a vertical load was applied to the implant to simulate the conditions of the bearing phase of gait. Second, a rotational load was applied to the implant. Torsional loading tests were found to be satisfactory for studying variations in shape of the proximal portion of femoral implants because they simulate the most critical loading conditions such as stair climbing or chair rising.
With the bonded implant-cement surface, bone stresses were rather distal, whereas they were mainly proximal with the debonded implant-cement interface. Under rotational loading, debonded implants produced less normal tensile and shear stresses in the proximal portion of the cement mantle. In contrast, compressive cement stresses were higher with debonded implants. In the debonded state, the rotational stability of the implant was found to be closely related to the degree of metaphyseal fill.
In conclusion, the use of implants with a debonded metal-cement interface and with optimal metaphyseal filling should preserve the cement-bone interface from excessive shear and tensile stresses, while providing good rotational stability.
通过有限元分析,研究近端髓腔填充和柄-骨水泥表面特性对股骨髋关节置换术中骨水泥和骨骼应力的联合影响。
我们对一个安装有不锈钢柄的股骨植入物进行了有限元研究,该研究基于4个模型,其干骺端填充量逐渐减少,旨在模拟骨水泥-骨界面出现任何退变之前的加载情况。因此,骨水泥被表示为与骨骼完全粘结。植入物-骨水泥界面模拟了粘结和脱粘状态。首先,对植入物施加垂直载荷以模拟步态支撑阶段的情况。其次,对植入物施加旋转载荷。发现扭转加载试验对于研究股骨植入物近端部分形状的变化是令人满意的,因为它们模拟了诸如爬楼梯或从椅子上起身等最关键的加载条件。
在植入物-骨水泥表面粘结的情况下,骨骼应力主要位于远端,而在植入物-骨水泥界面脱粘的情况下,骨骼应力主要位于近端。在旋转载荷下,脱粘的植入物在骨水泥套近端部分产生的法向拉伸和剪应力较小。相比之下,脱粘的植入物产生的骨水泥压缩应力较高。在脱粘状态下,发现植入物的旋转稳定性与干骺端填充程度密切相关。
总之,使用具有脱粘金属-骨水泥界面且干骺端填充最佳的植入物应能保护骨水泥-骨界面免受过大的剪切和拉伸应力,同时提供良好的旋转稳定性。