Gore J, Leonard B R, Gable R H
Louisiana State University AgCenter, Department of Entomology, 402 Life Science Building, Baton Rouge, LA 70803, USA.
J Econ Entomol. 2003 Jun;96(3):699-705. doi: 10.1093/jee/96.3.699.
Bollworm, Helicoverpa zea (Boddie), larvae are commonly observed feeding in genetically engineered Bollgard cotton. Although no information is currently available characterizing the levels of injury bollworms cause, aproximately 25% of the Bollgard acreage in the United States receives at least one insecticide application annually targeting bollworm populations. Studies were conducted to determine the levels of fruiting form injury that can occur from bollworm larvae feeding on white flowers of two types of genetically engineered cotton. The two types of genetically engineered cotton included the original Bollgard that produces one protein (Cry1Ac) from Bacillus thuringiensis variety kurstaki Berliner and Bollgard II that produces two proteins (Cry1Ac + Cry2Ab) from B. thuringiensis kurstaki. In one study, individual larvae (24 +/- 6 h old) were placed in first position white flowers of Deltapine 5415 (non-Bollgard) and Deltapine NuCOTN 33B (Bollgard). Larval infestations were made on 50 plants for each of 5 d during 2000 and 2001. Each plant was visually examined at 3 d and every 2 d thereafter, until larvae were no longer recovered. Larvae injured a total of 46.6 fruiting forms per 50 plants on non-Bollgard cotton, compared with only 18.9 fruiting forms per 50 plants on Bollgard cotton. Mean larval injury per insect was 4.3 fruiting forms on non-Bollgard cotton compared with 2.7 fruiting forms on Bollgard cotton. In a second study, individual larvae (24 +/- 6 h old) were placed in first position white flowers of Deltapine 50 (non-Bollgard), Deltapine 50B (Bollgard), and an experimental Bollgard II line. Larval infestations were made on 10 plants per day for each of six consecutive days during 2001. Larvae injured a total of 25.0 fruiting forms per 10 plants on non-Bollgard, 11.5 on Bollgard, and 6.4 on Bollgard II cottons. Mean larval injury per insect was 6.6 fruiting forms on non-Bollgard, 3.5 on Bollgard, and 0.8 on Bollgard II cottons. These data indicate that supplemental insecticide applications may be necessary to prevent yield losses on Bollgard cotton. In contrast, injury to Bollgard II cotton was minimal and may not require additional insecticide applications for bollworms.
棉铃虫,即烟芽夜蛾(Helicoverpa zea (Boddie)),其幼虫常在转基因抗虫棉(Bollgard棉)上取食。虽然目前尚无关于棉铃虫造成损伤程度的相关信息,但美国约25%的Bollgard棉种植面积每年至少要进行一次针对棉铃虫种群的杀虫剂施药。开展了多项研究,以确定棉铃虫幼虫取食两种转基因棉花的白花后可能造成的果枝损伤程度。这两种转基因棉花包括最初的Bollgard棉,它产生一种来自苏云金芽孢杆菌库尔斯塔克变种(Bacillus thuringiensis variety kurstaki Berliner)的蛋白质(Cry1Ac);以及Bollgard II棉,它产生两种来自苏云金芽孢杆菌库尔斯塔克变种的蛋白质(Cry1Ac + Cry2Ab)。在一项研究中,将个体幼虫(24 ± 6小时龄)放置在岱字棉5415(非Bollgard棉)和岱字棉NuCOTN 33B(Bollgard棉)的第一朵白花中。在2000年和2001年期间,连续5天,每天对50株植物进行幼虫侵染。在3天时对每株植物进行目视检查,此后每2天检查一次,直至不再发现幼虫。在非Bollgard棉上,幼虫对每50株植物造成的果枝损伤总数为46.6个,而在Bollgard棉上,每50株植物仅为18.9个。每只昆虫造成的平均幼虫损伤,在非Bollgard棉上为4.3个果枝,在Bollgard棉上为2.7个果枝。在第二项研究中,将个体幼虫(24 ± 6小时龄)放置在岱字棉50(非Bollgard棉)、岱字棉50B(Bollgard棉)和一个实验性Bollgard II品系的第一朵白花中。在2×span>01年期间,连续6天,每天对10株植物进行幼虫侵染。在非Bollgard棉上,幼虫对每10株植物造成的果枝损伤总数为25.0个,在Bollgard棉上为11.5个,在Bollgard II棉上为6.4个。每只昆虫造成的平均幼虫损伤,在非Bollgard棉上为6.6个果枝,在Bollgard棉上为3.5个果枝,在Bollgard II棉上为0.8个果枝。这些数据表明,可能需要额外施用杀虫剂以防止Bollgard棉的产量损失。相比之下,Bollgard II棉受到的损伤极小,可能无需针对棉铃虫额外施用杀虫剂。