Monaco Carlo, Ferrari Marco, Miceli Gian Paolo, Scotti Roberto
Department of Prosthetic Dentistry, School of Dentistry, University of Bologna, Italy.
Int J Prosthodont. 2003 May-Jun;16(3):319-25.
This clinical study evaluated the behavior of inlay fixed partial dentures (IFPD) with conventional and modified framework designs over a period of 12 to 48 months.
Forty-one glass fiber-reinforced composite IFPDs were made to replace one missing maxillary or mandibular tooth. The frameworks were made only with parallel fibers in 19 restorations (group 1) and built with parallel and woven fibers modifying the design of the pontic element in 22 IFPDs (group 2) according to the manufacturer's instructions. All restorations were evaluated by color match, marginal discoloration, secondary caries, surface texture, marginal adaptation, fracture, and postoperative sensitivity.
Three partial adhesive-cohesive veneering composite fractures occurred in the pontic element in group 1 after 3, 4, and 8 months, respectively. One cohesive fracture occurred in an abutment in group 2 after 46 months. Group 1 showed a 16% fracture failure rate; group 2 showed a 5% failure rate. However, no statistical difference was detected between the groups. IFPDs received the highest score at the following rates: color match 71%, marginal discoloration 96%, secondary caries 99%, surface texture 88%, marginal adaptation 98%, fracture 90%, and postoperative sensitivity 100%. Statistical analysis indicated significant deterioration of color match from baseline to last recall.
There were nonsignificantly fewer fractures of the veneering composite with the modified design of the framework than with the conventional design. Repair of the fractured veneer of IFPDs may lengthen the lifespan of the restorations, but it is advisable only for slight damage.
本临床研究评估了传统和改良框架设计的嵌体固定局部义齿(IFPD)在12至48个月期间的性能。
制作了41颗玻璃纤维增强复合材料IFPD,用于替换上颌或下颌的一颗缺失牙。根据制造商的说明,19个修复体的框架仅由平行纤维制成(第1组),22个IFPD的框架则由平行纤维和编织纤维制成,对桥体部分的设计进行了改良(第2组)。所有修复体均通过颜色匹配、边缘变色、继发龋、表面质地、边缘适应性、断裂和术后敏感性进行评估。
第1组的桥体部分分别在3个月、4个月和8个月后发生了3次部分粘结性贴面复合材料断裂。第2组在46个月后有一个基牙发生了粘结性断裂。第1组的断裂失败率为16%;第2组的失败率为5%。然而,两组之间未检测到统计学差异。IFPD在以下方面获得的高分率为:颜色匹配71%、边缘变色96%、继发龋99%、表面质地88%、边缘适应性98%、断裂90%和术后敏感性100%。统计分析表明,从基线到最后一次复查,颜色匹配有显著恶化。
与传统设计相比,框架改良设计的贴面复合材料断裂情况略少,但无统计学意义。IFPD断裂贴面的修复可能会延长修复体的使用寿命,但仅适用于轻微损坏的情况。