Ashwood N, Witt J D, Hallam P J, Cobb J P
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, The Middlesex Hospital, London, UK.
Ann R Coll Surg Engl. 2003 Jul;85(4):272-6. doi: 10.1308/003588403766275015.
To investigate the sources of delay in diagnosis and determine if there was a similar diagnostic error rate as found by the Musculoskeletal Tumour Society, which subsequently altered patients' management and affected outcome.
A prospective review of 100 consecutive patients referred to our institution analysed causes for delay in referral and whether prior investigations or procedures had complicated further management.
Patients were symptomatic for 14.8 months (range, 0-26 months) prior to consultation with their GP. A further 13.5 months (range, 0.5-120 months) elapsed before referral by the local hospital (94) or GP (6) to the bone and soft tissue service. A significant delay in referral of more than a month occurred in 72 patients. Those patients with malignant disease were symptomatic for 7.6 months (range, 0.5-11 months) prior to seeking medical advice with a further 7.5 months (range, 0-13 months) elapsing prior to onward referral at their local hospital. From the study group, 63 patients were subjected to complex imaging studies (bone scan, CT, MRI) prior to referral; 34 biopsies or surgery were performed in 34 cases by referring teams, 16 of which complicated subsequent management.
If a high suspicion of a soft tissue or bone tumour is suspected from the history, examination and plain radiograph, then early referral to a specialist centre is recommended where relevant, high-quality investigations can be arranged in a short time leading to a planned biopsy, confirmation of diagnosis and definitive treatment at an earlier stage.
调查诊断延迟的原因,并确定是否存在与肌肉骨骼肿瘤学会发现的相似的诊断错误率,该错误率随后改变了患者的治疗方案并影响了治疗结果。
对连续转诊至我院的100例患者进行前瞻性研究,分析转诊延迟的原因以及先前的检查或手术是否使后续治疗变得复杂。
患者在咨询全科医生之前有症状的时间为14.8个月(范围0 - 26个月)。在当地医院(94例)或全科医生(6例)将患者转诊至骨与软组织专科之前,又过去了13.5个月(范围0.5 - 120个月)。72例患者转诊延迟超过1个月。患有恶性疾病的患者在寻求医疗建议之前有症状的时间为7.6个月(范围0.5 - 11个月),在当地医院进一步转诊之前又过去了7.5个月(范围0 - 13个月)。在研究组中,63例患者在转诊前接受了复杂的影像学检查(骨扫描、CT、MRI);转诊团队对34例患者进行了34次活检或手术,其中16例使后续治疗变得复杂。
如果根据病史、检查和X线平片高度怀疑软组织或骨肿瘤,那么建议尽早转诊至专科中心,在那里可以在短时间内安排高质量的检查,从而在更早阶段进行有计划的活检、确诊和确定性治疗。