Clin Ther. 1992 Nov-Dec;14(6):895-909.
Flumazenil is a competitive benzodiazepine antagonist that rapidly reverses the residual effects of benzodiazepines following intravenous conscious sedation. In a double-blind, multicenter study, postoperative patients who had been sedated with intravenous diazepam were randomly allocated to receive intravenous doses of flumazenil (0.4 mg to 1 mg) or placebo. Levels of sedation and psychomotor impairment were evaluated prestudy, at baseline, and at 6 intervals from 5 to 180 minutes posttreatment. A global evaluation of effectiveness was made at the 5-minute assessment, and memory was assessed at the 180-minute assessment. Flumazenil (mean dose: 0.73 mg [7.3 ml]) was significantly more effective than placebo (mean dose: 8.9 ml) in reversing sedation, psychomotor impairment, and amnesia within 5 minutes after the start of administration. At the 5-minute posttreatment assessment, 84% of 102 flumazenil-treated patients (compared with 42% of 52 placebo-treated patients) experienced complete reversal of sedation. Ninety-two percent of 93 flumazenil-treated patients (compared with 41% of 46 placebo-treated patients) had normal psychomotor function. Reversal of amnesia at the 5-minute assessment was achieved in 75% of 101 flumazenil-treated patients and in 20% of 51 placebo-treated patients. Statistically significant differences between flumazenil and placebo were also observed at the 15-minute assessment. Thereafter there were no significant differences between the two treatment groups. Most (70%) flumazenil-treated patients exhibited no recurrence of sedation during the 180-minute assessment period. The most frequent adverse reaction in the flumazenil group was dizziness (6%). There were no serious adverse experiences related to the test drug. Flumazenil provided prompt, controlled reversal of residual effects, especially sedation, in the majority (84%) of patients recovering from intravenous conscious sedation induced by diazepam. For most (70%) of these flumazenil-treated patients, the reversal was maintained throughout the 180-minute assessment.
氟马西尼是一种竞争性苯二氮䓬拮抗剂,可迅速逆转静脉注射清醒镇静后苯二氮䓬的残留效应。在一项双盲、多中心研究中,接受静脉注射地西泮镇静的术后患者被随机分配接受静脉注射氟马西尼(0.4毫克至1毫克)或安慰剂。在研究前、基线以及治疗后5至180分钟的6个时间点评估镇静水平和精神运动功能损害情况。在5分钟评估时进行有效性的整体评估,在180分钟评估时评估记忆力。在给药开始后5分钟内,氟马西尼(平均剂量:0.73毫克[7.3毫升])在逆转镇静、精神运动功能损害和失忆方面明显比安慰剂(平均剂量:8.9毫升)更有效。在治疗后5分钟评估时,102例接受氟马西尼治疗的患者中有84%(相比之下,52例接受安慰剂治疗的患者中有42%)的镇静完全逆转。93例接受氟马西尼治疗的患者中有92%(相比之下,46例接受安慰剂治疗的患者中有41%)的精神运动功能正常。在5分钟评估时,101例接受氟马西尼治疗的患者中有75%的失忆得到逆转,51例接受安慰剂治疗的患者中有20%的失忆得到逆转。在15分钟评估时也观察到氟马西尼和安慰剂之间存在统计学显著差异。此后,两个治疗组之间没有显著差异。大多数(70%)接受氟马西尼治疗的患者在180分钟评估期内未出现镇静复发。氟马西尼组最常见的不良反应是头晕(6%)。没有与受试药物相关的严重不良事件。氟马西尼能迅速、可控地逆转大多数(84%)从静脉注射地西泮诱导的清醒镇静中恢复的患者的残留效应,尤其是镇静作用。对于大多数(70%)接受氟马西尼治疗的患者,这种逆转在整个180分钟评估期内持续存在。