McGrattan P, Humphreys M W
Northern Ireland Regional Genetics Centre, Belfast City Hospital Trust, Lisburn Road, Belfast BT9 7AB.
Ulster Med J. 2003 May;72(1):16-21.
M4Eo acute myeloid leukaemia (AML) patients with the typical chromosome 16 abnormalities have a favourable prognosis. These subtle 16q22 gene rearrangements can be difficult to detect by conventional cytogenetic methods and if missed could lead to the incorrect assignment of prognostic group and hence subsequent treatment strategies. We retrospectively studied 13 patients diagnosed with M4Eo AML for such chromosome 16 abnormalities comparing conventional cytogenetic (G-banding) and molecular (FISH) methods. G-banded analysis detected only 2 patients with definite chromosome 16 abnormalities whereas FISH detected 4 patients, one with the typical inversion and three with the typical chromosome 16 translocation. FISH analysis also confirmed a false +ve G-banded result in one patient and a false -ve G-banded result in another patient. Finally, FISH confirmed a deletion of one chromosome 16 homologue in another patient indicating a poor prognosis. The overall survival of patients with the typical 16q22 rearrangements (n=4) was also significantly better (P=0.007) than patients with normal chromosome 16 homologues or having other numerical and/or structural abnormalities (n=9). This set of data shows that FISH is a more accurate method for the detection of cryptic 16q22 gene rearrangements and because of the prognostic implications has become a mandatory test along with conventional cytogenetics for all newly diagnosed M4Eo AML patients in Northern Ireland.
伴有典型16号染色体异常的M4Eo急性髓系白血病(AML)患者预后良好。这些细微的16q22基因重排用传统细胞遗传学方法可能难以检测到,如果漏检可能导致预后分组错误,进而影响后续治疗策略。我们回顾性研究了13例诊断为M4Eo AML的患者,比较传统细胞遗传学(G显带)和分子(FISH)方法检测此类16号染色体异常的情况。G显带分析仅检测到2例有明确16号染色体异常的患者,而FISH检测到4例,其中1例为典型倒位,3例为典型16号染色体易位。FISH分析还证实1例患者G显带结果为假阳性,另1例患者为假阴性。最后,FISH证实另1例患者1条16号同源染色体缺失,提示预后不良。伴有典型16q22重排的患者(n = 4)的总生存期也显著优于16号染色体同源染色体正常或有其他数目和/或结构异常的患者(n = 9)(P = 0.007)。这组数据表明,FISH是检测隐匿性16q22基因重排更准确的方法,由于其对预后的影响,在北爱尔兰,FISH已成为所有新诊断的M4Eo AML患者与传统细胞遗传学检测一样的必检项目。