Roshan D, Curzon M E J, Fairpo C G
Department of Paediatric Dentistry, Leeds Dental Institute, University of Leeds, UK.
Eur J Paediatr Dent. 2003 Mar;4(1):21-7.
The purpose of the study was to determine if there had been any changes in the clinical practice and attitudes to the care of children by general dental practitioners over a ten year period from 1986 to 1996, following the introduction of a system of capitation payments in the United Kingdom.
A questionnaire was mailed to 1,290 general dental practitioners practicing in Yorkshire (UK) in an identical way to a previous survey ten years before. Practitioners were asked questions concerning their practice of dental caries prevention, behaviour management, restoration of primary teeth and pulp therapy. Responses were compared with the results of the 1986 survey.
Of the total of 687 replies (53.2% response) 61% practiced, or said they practiced, diet evaluation and gave dietary advice. Oral hygiene instruction was reported by 87% and 57% used fissure sealants. The routine use of amalgam, previously 80%, had declined to 35% in favour of glass ionomer cements (57%). There had been a significant improvement in the use of pulp therapy for primary teeth at 35% compared with previous 3%. The use of rubber dam also increased, but only from 0% before to 9% in the present study. The usage of stainless steel crowns had changed from 2% over ten years to 8% and strip crowns from 1% to 5%.
The use of paediatric dental techniques by general dental practitioners had generally increased, particularly in preventive measures and pulp treatment. Restorative techniques had marginally changed, but a dramatic shift away from amalgam had occurred. There was still a very low usage of stainless steel crowns and rubber dam was also not used to the extent that it should be.
本研究旨在确定自1986年至1996年英国引入按人头付费制度后的十年间,普通牙科医生在儿童护理的临床实践和态度方面是否发生了任何变化。
以与十年前的一项调查相同的方式,向在英国约克郡执业的1290名普通牙科医生邮寄了一份问卷。询问了医生有关预防龋齿、行为管理、乳牙修复和牙髓治疗的实践问题。将回复结果与1986年调查的结果进行比较。
在总共687份回复中(回复率为53.2%),61%的医生进行了或表示进行了饮食评估并提供饮食建议。87%的医生报告进行了口腔卫生指导,57%的医生使用了窝沟封闭剂。汞合金的常规使用率从前的80%降至35%,转而青睐玻璃离子水门汀(57%)。乳牙牙髓治疗的使用率从之前的3%显著提高到35%。橡皮障的使用也有所增加,但仅从之前的0%增加到本研究中的9%。不锈钢冠的使用率从十年间的2%变为8%,带环冠从1%变为5%。
普通牙科医生对儿童牙科技术的使用总体上有所增加,特别是在预防措施和牙髓治疗方面。修复技术略有变化,但已发生了从汞合金的显著转变。不锈钢冠的使用率仍然很低,橡皮障的使用也未达到应有的程度。