Barton Jason J S, Cherkasova Mariya
Department of Neurology and Ophthalmology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center and Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA 02215, USA.
Neurology. 2003 Jul 22;61(2):220-5. doi: 10.1212/01.wnl.0000071229.11658.f8.
Face imagery can access facial memories without the use of perceptual stimuli. Current data on the relation of imagery to the perceptual function and neuroanatomy of prosopagnosic patients are mixed, and little is known about the type of facial information patients can access through imagery.
The authors wished to determine 1) which lesions abolished face imagery in prosopagnosia, 2) if deficits in perceiving facial structure were paralleled by similar deficits in imagery, and 3) if covert recognition of faces correlated with the degree of residual imagery for faces.
The authors tested nine prosopagnosic patients who had been tested previously for perception of facial configuration and covert recognition of famous faces. The authors constructed a battery of 37 questions that asked subjects to imagine the faces of two celebrities and to choose which one had a certain facial property. Half were questions about facial features and half were about overall facial shape.
Imagery was abolished only by anterior temporal lesions. Imagery for facial shape but not features was degraded by lesions of the right hemisphere's fusiform face area, which severely impaired perception of facial configuration. Feature imagery was degraded only when there was associated left occipito-temporal damage. Covert recognition was found when either configural perception or imagery was severely damaged, but not when both were abnormal. In patients with impaired configural perception, covert recognition correlated with feature imagery, suggesting that feature-based processing may drive residual covert abilities in these patients.
Although anterior temporal cortex may be the site of facial memory stores, these data also support hypotheses that perceptual areas like the fusiform face area have parallel contributions to mental imagery. The data on covert recognition are consistent with a view that it is the residue of a partially damaged face-recognition network. Covert recognition may reflect the degree of damage across components of a network rather than mark a specific form of prosopagnosia or a dissociated pathway.
面部表象可以在不使用感知刺激的情况下唤起面部记忆。目前关于表象与面孔失认症患者的感知功能及神经解剖学关系的数据并不一致,对于患者能够通过表象获取的面部信息类型也知之甚少。
作者希望确定:1)面孔失认症中哪些病变会消除面部表象;2)面部结构感知缺陷是否与表象中的类似缺陷并行;3)对面孔的隐性识别是否与面部表象的残留程度相关。
作者测试了9名面孔失认症患者,这些患者之前已接受过面部构型感知和对名人面孔的隐性识别测试。作者构建了一组37个问题,要求受试者想象两位名人的面孔,并选择其中一位具有某种面部特征的名人。一半问题是关于面部特征,另一半是关于整体面部形状。
只有颞前叶病变会消除表象。右半球梭状面孔区的病变会使面部形状的表象而非特征表象退化,这严重损害了面部构型的感知。只有在伴有左侧枕颞叶损伤时,特征表象才会退化。当构型感知或表象严重受损时会发现隐性识别,但当两者都异常时则不会。在构型感知受损的患者中,隐性识别与特征表象相关,这表明基于特征的加工可能驱动了这些患者残留的隐性能力。
虽然颞前叶皮质可能是面部记忆存储的部位,但这些数据也支持这样的假设,即梭状面孔区等感知区域对心理表象也有平行的贡献。关于隐性识别的数据与这样一种观点一致,即它是部分受损的面部识别网络的残余。隐性识别可能反映了网络各组成部分的损伤程度,而不是标志着一种特定形式的面孔失认症或一条分离的通路。