de Zélicourt M, Dardennes R, Verdoux H, Gandhi G, Papatheodorou M-L, Edgell E T, Khoshnood B, Chomette E, Even C, Fagnani F
CEMKA-EVAL, 43, boulevard du Maréchal Joffre, 92340 Bourg-la-Reine.
Encephale. 2003 May-Jun;29(3 Pt 1):248-53.
Bipolar disorder is a chronic, highly disabling illness. However, few studies have evaluated the economic impact of this illness. The objective of this study was to estimate: 1) the annual number of manic episodes in patients with bipolar I disorder, and 2) the costs of hospitalisations related to manic episodes in France. We only included data on bipolar I disorder, as there is greater consensus and better documentation for this subgroup of patients with bipolar disorder. The prevalence of manic episodes was estimated using published epidemiological data. A computerised literature search was performed using the traditional scientific and medical databases. Additional epidemiological references were identified from published studies and textbooks. For hospitalisation data, we used the statistics of the Medical Information Department of a large psychiatric hospital in Paris for the year 1999. We estimated the annual number of manic episodes in France based on: 1) the lifetime prevalence of bipolar I disorder, 2) the average cycle duration, 3) the proportion of rapid cycling patients, and 4) the proportion of depressive vs. manic episodes for patients with bipolar I disorder. In order to estimate the prevalence of bipolar I disorder, we conducted a random effects meta-analysis using published international data. Results of the meta-analysis, which was based on a total of 62 736 patients, showed the lifetime prevalence of bipolar I disorder to be 0.82% [95% CI: 0.42, 1.21]. Applied to the adult population in France, this prevalence implies that the number of persons who have ever experienced a bipolar I -disorder is approximately 390,000 [95% CI: 200,000, 575,000]. Few studies provide information on the duration of cycles in patients with bipolar I disorder. Available estimates suggest the cycle duration to be approximately 12 months. Regarding the proportion of rapid cyclers, data from the meta-analysis by Tondo et al. show that 18% of patients with bipolar disorder experience at least four episodes of mood disorder per year. Finally, based on findings provided by cohort studies, the number of depressive episodes appears to be roughly equal to the number of manic episodes during the course of bipolar disorder. A rapid cycling rate of 18% and a cycle duration of 12 months imply that, on average, among 100 bipolar patients, 18 will have a 3-month cycle duration and 82 a 14-month cycle duration. Given an equal proportion of manic and depressive episodes, the annual number of manic episodes would then be 68 for a cohort of 100 bipolar patients (0.68 episode per patient per year). Applying this figure to the estimate of the total number of patients with bipolar I disorder in France suggests that the annual number of manic episodes in France is 265,000 [95% CI: 136,000, 391,000]. Based on data from a psychiatric hospital in Paris, the proportion of manic episodes that require hospitalisation was estimated to be around 63% with an average length of stay of 32.4 days. Hence the annual number of hospitalisations for manic episodes in France is estimated to be 167 000 [95% CI: 86 000, 246 000] and the hospitalisation-related costs 1,3 billion euros approximately. Our review of literature highlights the lack of medical and economic data at the national level on the frequency and hospitalisation-related costs of manic episodes in patients with bipolar I disorder in France. Given the lifetime prevalence of bipolar I disorder which may be as high as 3% among adults, further studies are required in order to provide representative national data and to allow economic evaluations of costs related to bipolar disorder in France.
双相情感障碍是一种慢性、严重致残的疾病。然而,很少有研究评估这种疾病的经济影响。本研究的目的是估计:1)I型双相情感障碍患者每年躁狂发作的次数,以及2)法国与躁狂发作相关的住院费用。我们仅纳入了关于I型双相情感障碍的数据,因为对于双相情感障碍患者的这一亚组,有更多的共识和更好的记录。躁狂发作的患病率是根据已发表的流行病学数据估计的。使用传统的科学和医学数据库进行了计算机文献检索。从已发表的研究和教科书中确定了其他流行病学参考文献。对于住院数据,我们使用了巴黎一家大型精神病医院医学信息部1999年的统计数据。我们基于以下因素估计法国每年躁狂发作的次数:1)I型双相情感障碍的终生患病率,2)平均周期持续时间,3)快速循环患者的比例,以及4)I型双相情感障碍患者抑郁发作与躁狂发作的比例。为了估计I型双相情感障碍的患病率,我们使用已发表的国际数据进行了随机效应荟萃分析。荟萃分析的结果基于总共62736名患者,显示I型双相情感障碍的终生患病率为0.82%[95%置信区间:0.42,1.21]。将这一患病率应用于法国成年人口,意味着曾经经历过I型双相情感障碍的人数约为390000人[95%置信区间:200000,575000]。很少有研究提供关于I型双相情感障碍患者周期持续时间的信息。现有的估计表明周期持续时间约为12个月。关于快速循环者的比例,Tondo等人的荟萃分析数据显示,18%的双相情感障碍患者每年至少经历四次情绪障碍发作。最后,根据队列研究的结果,在双相情感障碍病程中,抑郁发作的次数似乎大致等于躁狂发作的次数。18%的快速循环率和12个月的周期持续时间意味着,平均而言,在100名双相情感障碍患者中,18人将有3个月的周期持续时间,82人将有14个月的周期持续时间。考虑到躁狂发作和抑郁发作的比例相等,那么对于100名双相情感障碍患者的队列,每年躁狂发作的次数将为68次(每名患者每年0.68次发作)。将这一数字应用于法国I型双相情感障碍患者总数的估计表明,法国每年躁狂发作的次数为265000次[95%置信区间:136000,391000]。根据巴黎一家精神病医院的数据,需要住院治疗的躁狂发作比例估计约为63%,平均住院时间为32.4天。因此,法国每年因躁狂发作住院的次数估计为167000次[95%置信区间:86000,246000],与住院相关的费用约为13亿欧元。我们对文献的综述强调,法国缺乏关于I型双相情感障碍患者躁狂发作频率和与住院相关费用的国家层面的医学和经济数据。鉴于I型双相情感障碍在成年人中的终生患病率可能高达3%,需要进一步研究以提供具有代表性的国家数据,并对法国双相情感障碍相关费用进行经济评估。