New John P, Mason James M, Freemantle Nick, Teasdale Sue, Wong Louise M, Bruce Nick J, Burns John A, Gibson John M
Department of Diabetes, Hope Hospital, Salford, UK.
Diabetes Care. 2003 Aug;26(8):2250-5. doi: 10.2337/diacare.26.8.2250.
To determine the effectiveness of specialist nurse-led clinics for hypertension and hyperlipidemia provided for diabetic patients receiving hospital-based care.
This study was a randomized controlled implementation trial at Hope Hospital, Salford, U.K. The subjects consisted of 1,407 subjects presenting for annual review with raised blood pressure(>or=140/80 mmHg), raised total cholesterol (>or=5.0 mmol/l), or both. Individuals with diabetes were randomized to usual care or usual care with subsequent invitation to attend specialist nurse-led clinics. Nurses provided clinics for participants, with attendance every 4-6 weeks, until targets were achieved. Lifestyle advice and titration of drug therapies were provided according to the locally agreed upon guidelines. Patients with both conditions were eligible for enrollment in either or both clinics. At subsequent annual review, blood pressure and total cholesterol values were obtained from the Salford electronic diabetes register. Data relating to deaths were obtained from the national strategic tracing service. The primary outcome was the odds ratio of achieving targets in hypertension and hyperlipidemia, attributable to the specialist nurse-led intervention.
Overall, specialist nurse-led clinics were associated with a significant improvement in patients achieving the target after 1 year (odds ratio [OR] 1.37 [95% CI 1.11-1.69], P = 0.003). This primary analysis revealed a borderline difference in effect between the two types of clinics (test for interaction between groups: P = 0.06). Secondary analysis, consistent with the prior beliefs of the health care professionals involved, suggested that targets were achieved more frequently in patients enrolled in the specialist nurse-led clinic for hyperlipidemia (OR 1.69 [1.25-2.29], P = 0.0007) than for hypertension (OR 1.14 [0.86-1.51], P = 0.37). Intervention (enrolled to either or both clinics) was associated with a reduction in all-cause mortality (OR 0.55 [0.32-0.92], P = 0.02).
This study provides good evidence to support the use of specialist nurse-led clinics as an effective adjunct to hospital-based care of patients with diabetes. If the standards of care recommended in the National Service Framework for Diabetes are to be achieved, then such proven methods for delivering care must be adopted.
确定由专科护士主导的诊所对接受医院治疗的糖尿病患者的高血压和高脂血症的治疗效果。
本研究是在英国索尔福德希望医院进行的一项随机对照实施试验。研究对象包括1407名前来进行年度复查的受试者,这些受试者的血压升高(≥140/80 mmHg)、总胆固醇升高(≥5.0 mmol/l)或两者兼有。糖尿病患者被随机分为接受常规护理组或接受常规护理并随后受邀参加由专科护士主导的诊所的组。护士为参与者开设诊所,每4 - 6周就诊一次,直至达到目标。根据当地商定的指南提供生活方式建议和药物治疗的滴定。患有这两种病症的患者有资格参加其中一个或两个诊所。在随后的年度复查中,从索尔福德电子糖尿病登记处获取血压和总胆固醇值。与死亡相关的数据从国家战略追踪服务处获取。主要结局是因专科护士主导的干预而实现高血压和高脂血症目标的比值比。
总体而言,由专科护士主导的诊所在1年后与患者实现目标的显著改善相关(比值比[OR]为1.37[95%置信区间1.11 - 1.69],P = 0.003)。这一初步分析显示两种类型的诊所在效果上存在临界差异(组间交互作用检验:P = 0.06)。与参与的医疗保健专业人员的先前看法一致的二次分析表明,参加由专科护士主导的高脂血症诊所的患者比参加高血压诊所的患者更频繁地实现目标(OR为1.69[1.25 - 2.29],P = 0.0007),而高血压诊所的OR为1.14[0.86 - 1.51],P = 0.37)。干预(参加其中一个或两个诊所)与全因死亡率降低相关(OR为0.55[0.32 - 0.92],P = 0.02)。
本研究提供了有力证据,支持使用由专科护士主导的诊所作为对糖尿病患者进行医院治疗的有效辅助手段。如果要实现《糖尿病国家服务框架》中推荐的护理标准,那么必须采用这种经证实的护理提供方法。