New J P, Mason J M, Freemantle N, Teasdale S, Wong L, Bruce N J, Burns J A, Gibson J M
Department of Diabetes, Hope Hospital, Salford, UK.
Diabet Med. 2004 Jun;21(6):599-603. doi: 10.1111/j.1464-5491.2004.01213.x.
To determine the effectiveness of specialist nurse delivered education in primary care to improve control of hypertension and hyperlipidaemia in patients with diabetes.
Practice-level randomized controlled trial, Salford, England.
From 44 practices, 10 303 subjects presenting in general practice with raised blood pressure (= 140/80 mmHg), raised total cholesterol (= 5.0 mmol/l) or both.
Practices were randomized to receive either the intervention for hyperlipidaemia or for hypertension; practices acted as control for the intervention not received. Specialist nurses arranged a schedule of visits with general practitioners and general practice nurses, reminding them of diabetes protocols and clinical targets. They provided educational materials and protocols used in secondary care for nurse and doctor interventions including stepping up pharmacotherapy when necessary. Practices received a list of patients in their practice who were poorly controlled at their last annual review; new and recalled patients were targeted.
At subsequent annual review, blood pressure and total cholesterol values were obtained from the Salford electronic diabetes register for patients from participating practices.
Overall, specialist nurse-led educational outreach to primary care was associated with no improvement in patients achieving target after 1 year-odds ratio (OR): 1.03 (95% CI 0.95-1.11; P = 0.52). Similar results were achieved with hyperlipidaemia OR: 1.04 (95% CI 0.88-1.23; P = 0.62) and hypertension OR: 1.01 (95% CI 0.80-1.27; P = 0.93).
This study provides evidence that the use of specialist nurses to perform educational outreach to improve target adherence to patients with diabetes in primary care is not effective.
确定专科护士在初级保健中提供教育,以改善糖尿病患者高血压和高脂血症控制情况的有效性。
实践水平的随机对照试验,英国索尔福德。
来自44家诊所的10303名患者,这些患者在全科诊所就诊时血压升高(≥140/80 mmHg)、总胆固醇升高(≥5.0 mmol/l)或两者皆有。
诊所被随机分配接受高脂血症或高血压干预;未接受的干预措施的诊所作为对照。专科护士安排与全科医生和全科诊所护士的访视计划,提醒他们糖尿病诊疗方案和临床目标。他们提供二级保健中用于护士和医生干预的教育材料和诊疗方案,包括必要时加强药物治疗。诊所收到其诊所内上次年度复查时控制不佳的患者名单;针对新患者和召回患者。
在随后的年度复查中,从索尔福德电子糖尿病登记册获取参与诊所患者的血压和总胆固醇值。
总体而言,专科护士主导的针对初级保健的教育推广在1年后与患者达到目标情况的改善无关——优势比(OR):1.03(95%可信区间0.95 - 1.11;P = 0.52)。高脂血症的结果相似——OR:1.04(95%可信区间0.88 - 1.23;P = 0.62),高血压——OR:1.01(95%可信区间0.80 - 1.27;P = 0.93)。
本研究提供的证据表明,在初级保健中使用专科护士进行教育推广以提高糖尿病患者对目标的依从性是无效的。