Liu Xiao-qing, Zhong Nan-shan, Chen Si-bei, He Wei-qun, Li Yi-min
Institute of Respiratory Disease, Guangzhou Medical College Hospital, Guangzhou 510120, China.
Zhongguo Yi Xue Ke Xue Yuan Xue Bao. 2003 Jun;25(3):363-7.
To evaluate the use of clinical nutritional support in critical SARS patients, and the relationship between blood glucose levels/insulin administration amount and outcome.
Twenty-one SARS patients who reached the standard of Ministry of Health's "critical level" were transferred into our ICU in an average of 11 days after onset and enrolled in this clinical trial. All patients underwent respiratory support and clinical nutrition support as scheduled. For about 60 kg patient per day 3347.2 kJ(800 kcal), 36 g protein, and 125 g carbohydrate was given intravenously; 4184 kJ(1000 kcal), 38 g protein, and 125 g carbohydrate was provided by enteral route. MCT/LCT as fat resource shared 50% calories intake. All patients received similar doses of intravenous Methylprednisolone(about 200 mg/d). Blood glucose, serum albumin, blood lymphocyte counts, and serum alanine transminase (ALT) were checked on the first admission day in ICU and on the 12th day after nutrition therapy was started. Insulin was started to pump in to maintain the blood glucose levels between 4.44-7.78 mmol/L (80-140 mg/dl) when the levels exceeded normal range.
Upon admission into ICU, all patients had poor nutrients intake for an average of 11 days and 16 patients (76.2%) were diagnosed as malnutrition. Parenteral and enteral nutrition therapy were then offered for an average of 12 days. On the 12th day, the serum albumin increased [(28.5 +/- 2.2)] g/L vs (37.0 +/- 4.1) g/L] (P = 0.0001) and so did the lymphocytes count [(0.74 +/- 0.47)] x 10(9)/L vs (1.22 +/- 0.73) x 10(9)/L] (P = 0.02). The blood glucose maintained at lower level in the surviving patients when compared with those who died [(9.5 +/- 2.3) mmol/L vs (6.3 +/- 1.8) mmol/L] [(196 +/- 70) mg/dl vs (110 +/- 21) mg/dl] (P = 0.0002), and the abnormally high ALT levels presented in some of the patients decreased but not significantly (81.0% vs 57.1%) (P = 0.18). In order to keep blood glucose within the range 4.44-7.78 mmol/L (80-140 mg/dl), only 18.8% of the surviving patients needed insulin intervention as opposed to 80.0% of those who died (P = 0.03). The amount of insulin used in the surviving group was significant lower than that in the group who died [(24 +/- 2) IU/d vs (72 +/- 9) IU/d] (P = 0.01).
Eleven days after SARS onset, most of the critical patients presented with malnutrition. Some improved nutrition related parameters may be associated with clinical nutritional support. The surviving patients required less insulin when compared to those who died. 80.0% of the patients who died need insulin versus only 18.8% of the surviving patients. Due to the difficulty of SARS management, this study was not a randomized controlled clinical trial. More clinical trials will be needed for checking the results of this investigation.
评估临床营养支持在重症SARS患者中的应用,以及血糖水平/胰岛素使用量与预后的关系。
21例达到卫生部“重症标准”的SARS患者,在发病后平均11天转入我院重症监护病房(ICU)并纳入本临床试验。所有患者均按计划接受呼吸支持和临床营养支持。对于体重约60kg的患者,每天静脉给予3347.2kJ(800kcal)、36g蛋白质和125g碳水化合物;经肠道途径给予4184kJ(1000kcal)、38g蛋白质和125g碳水化合物。中链甘油三酯/长链甘油三酯(MCT/LCT)作为脂肪来源,提供50%的热量摄入。所有患者接受相似剂量的静脉注射甲泼尼龙(约200mg/d)。在入住ICU的第一天和营养治疗开始后的第12天检查血糖、血清白蛋白、血淋巴细胞计数和血清丙氨酸转氨酶(ALT)。当血糖水平超过正常范围时,开始泵入胰岛素以维持血糖水平在4.44 - 7.78mmol/L(80 - 140mg/dl)之间。
入住ICU时,所有患者平均11天营养摄入不佳,16例(76.2%)被诊断为营养不良。随后给予肠外和肠内营养治疗,平均12天。在第12天,血清白蛋白升高[(28.5±2.2)g/L对(37.0±4.1)g/L](P = 0.0001),淋巴细胞计数也升高[(0.74±0.47)×10⁹/L对(1.22±0.73)×10⁹/L](P = 0.02)。与死亡患者相比,存活患者的血糖维持在较低水平[(9.5±2.3)mmol/L对(6.3±1.8)mmol/L][(196±70)mg/dl对(110±21)mg/dl](P = 0.0002),部分患者异常升高的ALT水平有所下降但不显著(81.0%对57.1%)(P = 0.18)。为使血糖维持在4.44 - 7.78mmol/L(80 - 140mg/dl)范围内,仅18.8%的存活患者需要胰岛素干预,而死亡患者为80.0%(P = 0.03)。存活组使用的胰岛素量显著低于死亡组[(24±2)IU/d对(72±9)IU/d](P = 0.01)。
SARS发病11天后,大多数重症患者出现营养不良。一些营养相关参数的改善可能与临床营养支持有关。与死亡患者相比,存活患者需要的胰岛素较少。80.0%的死亡患者需要胰岛素,而存活患者仅为18.8%。由于SARS管理的困难,本研究并非随机对照临床试验。需要更多的临床试验来验证本研究结果。