Partnerships with health and private voluntary organizations: what are the issues for health authorities and boards?

Coid D R, Williams B, Crombie I K

Director of Medical Services, Armadale Health Service, PO Box 460, Armadale 6992, Western Australia.

Public Health. 2003 Sep;117(5):317-22. doi: 10.1016/S0033-3506(03)00073-8.

BACKGROUND

The number of voluntary organizations active in health care is considerable. There have been recent calls for a new closer working relationship between voluntary bodies and the National Health Service. The relationship between the two healthcare sectors needs to be efficient and harmonious in the interests of patient care; however, little is known about the nature and problems in the current relationship. The present study was undertaken to examine aspects of this relationship from the point of view of health board personnel.

OBJECTIVE

To identify the practices and views of Scottish health board staff concerning the funding, role and responsibility of voluntary organizations in the health sector.

METHODS

A qualitative study based on in-depth interviews with health board officials in all 15 Scottish health boards.

RESULTS

Policies for financial and other relationships with the voluntary sector were often not explicit. The levels and method of funding voluntary health organizations varied across boards, as did the tenure of awards (from 1 to 3 years). Demand for funding far exceeded monies available. Some health boards ensured accountability through audited accounts, annual reports and site visits; however, others thought this inappropriate for small organizations. Health boards recognized the problems of the precariousness of funding and the administrative burden of the monitoring process and the ritual of applying for funding.

CONCLUSION

The uncertainties of long-term funding may impede the contribution of voluntary organizations. There is a tension between the requirements of clinical governance and the ability of small voluntary organizations to provide the necessary documentation. One proposed solution, to reduce the number of organizations, might not appeal to the voluntary sector. Future initiatives could address the problem of tailoring funding and accounting to the resources of voluntary organizations.