Jensen A L, Houe H, Nielsen C G
Department of Clinical Studies, Royal Veterinary and Agricultural University, Frederiksberg, Denmark.
J Comp Pathol. 1992 Nov;107(4):373-8. doi: 10.1016/0021-9975(92)90011-i.
The critical difference, which may help to judge whether the difference between two consecutive analytical results may be safely ascribed to natural variation or not, was calculated for 12 clinical chemical components determined in blood samples collected once a week for 5 consecutive weeks from 19 clinically healthy Red Danish dairy cows. For each clinical chemical component, the total variance of the analytical results was divided into the component of variance between cows (S2Inter), the component of variance for weeks within cows (S2Intra) and the component of variance for measurements (S2Anal) using nested analysis of variance. The critical difference calculated in absolute values from S2Intra and S2Anal was 0.15 mu kat per 1 for alanine aminotransferase, 0.55 mu kat per 1 for aspartate aminotransferase, 0.57 mu kat per 1 for alkaline phosphatase, 0.14 mu kat per 1 for gamma-glutamyltransferase, 1.95 mu kat per 1 for creatine kinase, 2.23 mmol per 1 for urea, 22 mu mol per 1 for creatinine, 2.4 g per 1 for albumin, 10.0 g per 1 for serum protein Total, 0.71 mmol per 1 for glucose, 0.54 mmol per 1 for calcium and 0.25 mmol per 1 for magnesium. These critical differences may be used as guidelines to evaluate the difference between two consecutive analytical results in cows. However, the analytical results should not be assessed by the critical differences alone, but should also be compared with the corresponding reference intervals.
对19头临床健康的丹麦红牛连续5周每周采集一次血样,测定其中12种临床化学成分,计算出临界差值,该差值有助于判断两个连续分析结果之间的差异是否可安全归因于自然变异。对于每种临床化学成分,使用嵌套方差分析将分析结果的总方差分为牛之间的方差分量(S2Inter)、牛内各周的方差分量(S2Intra)和测量的方差分量(S2Anal)。由S2Intra和S2Anal计算得出的绝对值临界差值,对于丙氨酸氨基转移酶为每升0.15微卡特,天冬氨酸氨基转移酶为每升0.55微卡特,碱性磷酸酶为每升0.57微卡特,γ-谷氨酰转移酶为每升0.14微卡特,肌酸激酶为每升1.95微卡特,尿素为每升2.23毫摩尔,肌酐为每升22微摩尔,白蛋白为每升2.4克,血清总蛋白为每升10.0克,葡萄糖为每升0.71毫摩尔,钙为每升0.54毫摩尔,镁为每升0.25毫摩尔。这些临界差值可作为评估奶牛两个连续分析结果之间差异的指导原则。然而,分析结果不应仅通过临界差值来评估,还应与相应的参考区间进行比较。