Nelson John
Can HIV AIDS Policy Law Rev. 2003 Apr;8(1):69-70.
On 9 October 2002, a majority of South Africa's Constitutional Court dismissed appeals from convictions for prostitution and keeping a brothel, rejecting arguments that the law was unconstitutional. However, the minority decision, endorsed by five of eleven judges, found that the provision that made the sex worker but not the client guilty of a criminal offence was discriminatory and should be struck down.
2002年10月9日,南非宪法法院的多数法官驳回了对卖淫及经营妓院定罪的上诉,驳回了该法律违宪的论点。然而,由11名法官中的5名支持的少数派裁决认为,规定性工作者而非嫖客有罪的条款具有歧视性,应予以废除。