Triglia J M, Nicollas R, Roman S, Paris J
CHU La Timone, Service d'ORL Pédiatrique et de chirurgie cervico-faciale, boulevard Jean Moulin, F-13385 Marseille, France.
Rev Laryngol Otol Rhinol (Bord). 2003;124(1):65-9.
To assess and compare long term results after surgical correction (transnasal or transplatine approaches) of unilateral or bilateral choanal atresia, in children with or without associated anomalies.
During a 13-year period, 58 children were included in this retrospective study. Seventy-five choanas were operated on (41 unilateral and 17 bilateral). The transpalatine approach was performed in 41 children (56 choanas) while the transnasal approach was performed in 17 patients (19 choanas). Associated anomalies were reported in 28 children and corresponded to CHARGE association in 13 cases.
With a mean follow-up of 7 years, perfect choanal permeability was reported in 90% of children operated on through a transpalatine approach and in 76% of children with a transnasal approach. A complementary therapeutic procedure was required in 54% of transpalatine approaches and 46% of transnasal approaches to yield these results. Postoperative choanal permeability was obtained in 93% of children without an associated anomaly and in 77% of those with associated anomalies, such as in 88% of unilateral atresias and 80% of bilateral ones.
Initial success rate after surgery is similar for all surgical procedure insofar as nearly half choanas required a complementary therapeutic procedure. The endonasal procedure using the microdebrider appears hopeful and the KTP laser is interesting in fibrous residual stenosis. Associated anomalies are factors which lower general prognosis while inducing a higher surgical failure rate.
评估和比较采用经鼻或经腭入路手术矫正单侧或双侧后鼻孔闭锁的长期效果,观察对象为伴有或不伴有相关畸形的儿童。
在13年期间,58名儿童纳入该回顾性研究。共对75个后鼻孔进行了手术(41个单侧,17个双侧)。41名儿童(56个后鼻孔)采用经腭入路,17名患者(19个后鼻孔)采用经鼻入路。28名儿童报告有相关畸形,其中13例符合CHARGE综合征。
平均随访7年,经腭入路手术的儿童中90%后鼻孔通气良好,经鼻入路手术的儿童中76%后鼻孔通气良好。为达到这些结果,经腭入路手术的54%和经鼻入路手术的46%需要辅助治疗。无相关畸形的儿童中93%术后后鼻孔通气良好,有相关畸形的儿童中77%术后后鼻孔通气良好,单侧闭锁的儿童中88%、双侧闭锁的儿童中80%术后后鼻孔通气良好。
所有手术方式的初始成功率相似,因为近一半的后鼻孔需要辅助治疗。使用微型清创器的鼻内手术似乎有前景,KTP激光对纤维性残余狭窄有作用。相关畸形是降低总体预后并导致手术失败率更高的因素。