Nishimura A, Shioiri T, Nushida H, Ueno Y, Ushiyama I, Tanegashima A, Someya T, Nishi K
Department of Legal Medicine, Shiga University of Medical Science, Ohtsu, Japan.
Leg Med (Tokyo). 1999 Sep;1(3):150-8. doi: 10.1016/s1344-6223(99)80028-5.
Some researchers have emphasized that, from the perspective of suicide prevention, research into the methods of suicide seemed to be particularly promising, as it has been shown repeatedly that restricting access to the prevailing method of suicide in a country will decrease suicide rates and that the lethality of the method used significantly correlated with the degree of intention to die. In this study, we examined changes in choice of method and the lethality score between the last attempted suicide (LAS) and completed suicide (CS) in 416 victims (male: 197, female: 219) to point out the tendency on their choice of method in LAS and CS. There was a significant difference in choice of suicide method between LAS and CS, and injury to themselves (33.7%) was the most common method of LAS, while hanging (37.5%) was the most common method of CS. The mean lethality score of CS method was significantly higher than that of LAS method in both sex groups, suggesting that at least one of the causes that drives suicide attempters to commit suicide finally may be the difference in the lethalities of LAS and CS. At the time of CS, suicidal victims tend to choose the same method as that of LAS again. These findings suggest that although suicide attempters tend to choose the same method, they will use a more lethal method if they change the suicide method. Interestingly, moreover, there was no sex difference in the percentage of the mean lethality score at CS.
一些研究人员强调,从自杀预防的角度来看,对自杀方法的研究似乎特别有前景,因为反复表明,限制一个国家普遍使用的自杀方法的可及性会降低自杀率,而且所使用方法的致死性与想死的意愿程度显著相关。在本研究中,我们调查了416名受害者(男性:197名,女性:219名)上次自杀未遂(LAS)和自杀死亡(CS)之间自杀方法选择和致死性评分的变化,以指出他们在LAS和CS中自杀方法选择的倾向。LAS和CS之间自杀方法的选择存在显著差异,自我伤害(33.7%)是LAS最常见的方法,而缢吊(37.5%)是CS最常见的方法。在两个性别组中,CS方法的平均致死性评分均显著高于LAS方法,这表明至少有一个促使自杀未遂者最终自杀的原因可能是LAS和CS致死性的差异。在CS时,自杀受害者倾向于再次选择与LAS相同的方法。这些发现表明,尽管自杀未遂者倾向于选择相同的方法,但如果他们改变自杀方法,会使用更具致死性的方法。此外,有趣的是,CS时平均致死性评分的百分比不存在性别差异。