Valls Carlos, Andía Eduard, Sánchez Anna, Moreno Victor
Institut de Diagnòstic per la imatge (IDI), Hospital Duran i Reynals, Ciutat Sanitària i Universitària de Bellvitge, Autovía de Castelldefels km 2,7, L'Hospitalet de Llobregat, 08907 Barcelona, Spain.
Eur Radiol. 2003 Aug;13(8):2000-5. doi: 10.1007/s00330-001-1190-4. Epub 2001 Dec 13.
The aim of this study was to describe our experience and institutional savings with a selective use of low-osmolality contrast media (LOCM) in CT. From 1995 to 1998, a total of 19,834 contrast-enhanced CT examinations were performed at our institution. Contrast was injected with a power injector and large venous catheter, 20-G for 2- to 3-ml rate and 18-G for 3- to 5-ml rate. High-osmolality contrast media was used in 13,670 patients (71%). The LOCM was used in 5884 (29%) patients. Our guidelines for the use of LOCM included cardiac dysfunction, severe pulmonary impairment, history of allergy or prior moderate reaction to HOCM and severe debilitation. Prior to the injection of HOCM, 10 mg of metoclopramide (Primperan, Delagrange Quétigny, France) were administered to reduce nausea and vomiting. In the HOCM group there were 304 minor or mild adverse reactions (2.2%), and 10 severe adverse reactions (0.08%). In the LOCM there were 34 mild or moderate adverse reactions (0.59%) and 3 severe adverse reactions (0.05%). Significant differences in terms of mild adverse reactions were found between HOCM and LOCM (Fischer's test, p<0.001). No significant differences were found in terms of severe adverse reactions ( p=0.27). After subtracting the cost of treating additional adverse reactions, the net differential cost between universal and selective use of LOCM was 565,285 Euro (601,067 US dollars). This means a net increase of 41.4 Euro per patient or 414,000 Euro per 10,000 patients (438,840 US dollars). Selective use of LOCM in CT is safe and effective and results in a substantial reduction in costs.
本研究的目的是描述我们在CT检查中选择性使用低渗造影剂(LOCM)的经验及机构节约情况。1995年至1998年,我们机构共进行了19834例增强CT检查。造影剂通过动力注射器和大静脉导管注入,20G导管用于2至3ml/秒的流速,18G导管用于3至5ml/秒的流速。13670例患者(71%)使用了高渗造影剂。5884例(29%)患者使用了低渗造影剂。我们使用低渗造影剂的指南包括心脏功能不全、严重肺功能损害、过敏史或既往对高渗造影剂有中度反应以及严重虚弱。在注射高渗造影剂之前,给予10mg甲氧氯普胺(胃复安,法国德拉格朗日·凯蒂尼公司生产)以减少恶心和呕吐。在高渗造影剂组,有304例轻微或轻度不良反应(2.2%),10例严重不良反应(0.08%)。在低渗造影剂组,有34例轻度或中度不良反应(0.59%)和3例严重不良反应(0.05%)。高渗造影剂和低渗造影剂在轻度不良反应方面存在显著差异(费舍尔检验,p<0.001)。在严重不良反应方面未发现显著差异(p=0.27)。扣除治疗额外不良反应的费用后,普遍使用和选择性使用低渗造影剂之间的净差异成本为565285欧元(601067美元)。这意味着每位患者净增加41.4欧元,或每10000例患者净增加414000欧元(438840美元)。在CT检查中选择性使用低渗造影剂是安全有效的,并且能大幅降低成本。