Shipton Deborah, Badley Elizabeth M, Mahomed Nizar N
Arthritis Community Research and Evaluation Unit, Toronoto Western Research Institute, Ontario, Canada.
J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2003 Sep;85(9):1710-5. doi: 10.2106/00004623-200309000-00009.
Questions regarding the adequacy of the current orthopaedic workforce in Canada to meet the present and future demands for orthopaedic services raise the need for accurate estimates of the supply and demand for orthopaedic services. The present study provides estimates of current supply of orthopaedic services in Ontario, the largest province of Canada, in order to allow for direct comparisons with data on workforce requirements.
All identified orthopaedic surgeons in Ontario were sent a self-administered questionnaire in 2000, which was similar to a previous survey in 1997. The age and gender of eligible respondents were obtained from the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario. One full-time-equivalent orthopaedist was assumed to have 2200 annual hours of direct patient contact and to provide forty-four weeks of clinical work per year.
The response rate was 94%. The mean age of the 337 active orthopaedic surgeons was forty-nine years, an increase of four years since 1997. Six percent of the respondents were women in both survey years. Approximately twenty-three half days of office and surgery time per 100,000 population were reported, which represents approximately two full-time equivalent orthopaedic surgeons per 100,000 population. On the average, eight half days of combined office and surgery time were reported per surgeon per week.
The estimated supply of orthopaedic surgeons in Ontario (two full-time equivalents per 100,000 population) falls short of the recently calculated requirement in the United States (5.6 full-time equivalents per 100,000 population). These data suggest that there is currently a shortage of orthopaedic services in Ontario, which will be exacerbated by the aging of a profession already working near full capacity.
关于加拿大当前骨科医疗人员能否满足骨科服务的现有及未来需求的问题,引发了对骨科服务供需情况进行准确估算的需求。本研究对加拿大最大的省份安大略省目前的骨科服务供给情况进行了估算,以便能与劳动力需求数据进行直接比较。
2000年,向安大略省所有已确认的骨科外科医生发放了一份自填式问卷,该问卷与1997年的一项先前调查类似。符合条件的受访者的年龄和性别信息来自安大略省医师和外科医生学院。假定一名全职等效骨科医生每年有2200小时的直接患者接触时间,且每年提供44周的临床工作。
回复率为94%。337名在职骨科外科医生的平均年龄为49岁,自1997年以来增加了4岁。在两个调查年份中,6%的受访者为女性。报告显示,每10万人口约有23个半天的门诊和手术时间,这相当于每10万人口约有两名全职等效骨科医生。平均而言,每位外科医生每周报告的门诊和手术总时间为8个半天。
安大略省骨科外科医生的估计供给量(每10万人口两名全职等效人员)低于美国最近计算出的需求量(每10万人口5.6名全职等效人员)。这些数据表明,安大略省目前存在骨科服务短缺的情况,而一个已经接近满负荷工作的行业的老龄化将使这一情况更加恶化。