Mennicken Françoise, Zhang Ji, Hoffert Cyrla, Ahmad Sultan, Beaudet Alain, O'Donnell Dajan
Molecular Sciences Department, AstraZeneca Research and Development Montreal, 7171 Frederick-Banting, St. Laurent, Quebec H4S 1Z9, Canada.
J Comp Neurol. 2003 Oct 20;465(3):349-60. doi: 10.1002/cne.10839.
To assess the validity of rodent models for investigating the role of delta opioid receptors (DOR) in analgesia, the distribution of DOR binding and mRNA were compared between rodent and primate spinal cord and dorsal root ganglia (DRG), using receptor autoradiography and in situ hybridization, respectively. In mouse and rat spinal cord, [(125)I]-deltorphin-labeled DOR binding sites were detected throughout the gray matter. In contrast, in primate and particularly in human spinal cord, DOR binding was mainly present in laminae I-II, with little to no binding in deeper layers. Accordingly, in rodent spinal cord, DOR mRNA was expressed by a large number of neurons distributed throughout the ventral and dorsal horns, whereas in the primate, DOR expression was significantly lower, as evidenced by a moderate number of labeled cells throughout the gray matter in monkey and by only few labeled cells in human, mainly in Clarke's column and lamina IX. Major species differences in DOR expression were also observed in primary afferent cells bodies. In rat DRG, intense DOR mRNA hybridization was primarily observed over large ganglion cells immunopositive for neurofilament 200. In contrast, in monkey and human DRG, DOR mRNA was primarily detected over small and medium-sized ganglion cells. These results demonstrate major differences in the expression and distribution of DOR in the spinal cord and DRG between mammalian species. Specifically, they point to a progressive specialization of DOR toward the regulation of primary somatosensory, namely nociceptive, inputs during phylogeny and suggest that the effects of DOR agonists in rodents may not be entirely predictive of their action in humans.
为评估啮齿动物模型在研究δ阿片受体(DOR)在镇痛中作用的有效性,分别使用受体放射自显影术和原位杂交技术,比较了啮齿动物与灵长类动物脊髓和背根神经节(DRG)中DOR结合及mRNA的分布情况。在小鼠和大鼠脊髓中,整个灰质均检测到[(125)I]-强啡肽标记的DOR结合位点。相比之下,在灵长类动物尤其是人类脊髓中,DOR结合主要存在于I-II层,深层几乎没有结合。相应地,在啮齿动物脊髓中,大量分布于腹角和背角的神经元表达DOR mRNA,而在灵长类动物中,DOR表达明显较低,如猴子整个灰质中有中等数量的标记细胞,而人类中仅有少量标记细胞,主要位于克拉克柱和IX层。在初级传入细胞体中也观察到DOR表达的主要物种差异。在大鼠DRG中,强烈的DOR mRNA杂交主要在对神经丝200免疫阳性的大神经节细胞上观察到。相比之下,在猴子和人类DRG中,DOR mRNA主要在中小型神经节细胞上检测到。这些结果表明哺乳动物物种之间脊髓和DRG中DOR的表达和分布存在主要差异。具体而言,它们指出在系统发育过程中DOR逐渐专门用于调节初级躯体感觉,即伤害性感受输入,并表明DOR激动剂在啮齿动物中的作用可能无法完全预测其在人类中的作用。