KAUFMAN J J, ROSENTHAL M, GOODWIN W E
Calif Med. 1954 Nov;81(5):308-13.
Four methods available for the diagnosis of carcinoma of the prostate-digital rectal evaluation, prostatic smear, needle biopsy and open perineal or transurethral biopsy-were studied and correlated.One hundred ten patients with clinical indications of cancer of the prostate were subjected to needle biopsy and open perineal or transurethral biopsy. Seventy of the same patients had prostatic smear examination. Using the open perineal biopsy or the positive transurethral biopsy as the standard, the accuracy of prostatic palpation, prostatic smear and needle biopsy were obtained.A high degree of correlation (74 per cent) was demonstrated between digital rectal evaluation and positive surgical biopsies in both early and late cases. There were 17 false positive clinical diagnoses. The prostatic smear showed an overall correlation of 45 per cent when compared with the results of positive surgical biopsy. The overall accuracy of needle biopsy was 73 per cent. However, in the last 39 cases, including eight in which the carcinomas were of groups A and B (curable), the needle accuracy was 100 per cent. When there is clinical indication of malignant disease of the prostate, needle biopsy of the lesion is warranted and should be done before definitive or palliative treatment is undertaken.
研究并对比了四种可用于前列腺癌诊断的方法——直肠指检、前列腺涂片、针吸活检以及开放性会阴或经尿道活检。110例有前列腺癌临床指征的患者接受了针吸活检以及开放性会阴或经尿道活检。其中70例患者进行了前列腺涂片检查。以开放性会阴活检或经尿道活检阳性作为标准,得出前列腺触诊、前列腺涂片及针吸活检的准确率。在早期和晚期病例中,直肠指检与手术活检阳性之间均显示出高度相关性(74%)。有17例临床诊断为假阳性。与手术活检阳性结果相比,前列腺涂片的总体相关性为45%。针吸活检的总体准确率为73%。然而,在最后39例病例中,包括8例A组和B组(可治愈)的癌肿病例,针吸活检准确率为100%。当有前列腺恶性疾病的临床指征时,对病变进行针吸活检是必要的,且应在进行确定性或姑息性治疗之前完成。