Jabourian A P, Erlich M, Desvignes C, el Hadjam M, Bitton R
Centre de Neurophysiologie, Paris.
Ann Med Psychol (Paris). 1992 Feb-Mar;150(2-3):240-4: discussion 245.
A 24 hour ambulatory EEG study performed in a population of 300 non epileptic outpatients with an anxious and depressive pathology revealed a high prevalence of abnormalities in subjects referred with panic disorder. Two groups of 150 medication-free patients each have been selected on the base of DSM-III-R = one with panic attacks (PA), the other with depressive patients without paroxystic anxiety (DS). The results showed respectively = in the PA group 63.2% abnormal, 19.7% normal and 17.1% dubious records. In the DS group = 74.5% normal, 18.3% abnormal and 7.2% dubious records. Epileptiform abnormalities were 4 times more frequent in the PA group (80%) than in the DS group (20%). Two nycthemeral peaks were found (5-8 pm and 3 hours after awakening). MRI has permitted the discovery of abnormal cerebral images in 3 patients of the PA group (cyst of the insula, temporal and parietal cryptic angiomas, sequelae of a parietal vasculo-cerebral stroke) frequency appearing to be clearly superior to the one resulting from recent epidemiologic data. The subclinical character of 2/3 of these abnormalities refers beyond epilepsy to their signification in the field of emotive and intellectual disturbances. The paradoxal efficiency of tricyclic drugs in panic disorder, sets the problem of their eventual antiepileptic action at low doses. If recent data on standard EEG in panic disorder is available, we did not find any similar study to ours in order to confront our results.
在300名患有焦虑和抑郁病症的非癫痫门诊患者中进行的一项24小时动态脑电图研究显示,患有惊恐障碍的受试者中异常情况的发生率很高。根据《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》第三版修订本(DSM-III-R),选取了两组各150名未服用药物的患者,一组有惊恐发作(PA),另一组是没有阵发性焦虑的抑郁症患者(DS)。结果分别显示,在PA组中,63.2%的记录异常,19.7%正常,17.1%可疑。在DS组中,74.5%正常,18.3%异常,7.2%可疑。PA组的癫痫样异常发生率(80%)是DS组(20%)的4倍。发现了两个昼夜高峰(下午5点至8点以及醒来后3小时)。MRI检查发现PA组有3名患者的脑部图像异常(岛叶囊肿、颞叶和顶叶隐匿性血管瘤、顶叶脑血管中风后遗症),其出现频率似乎明显高于近期流行病学数据显示的频率。这些异常情况中有三分之二的亚临床特征不仅超出了癫痫的范畴,还涉及到它们在情感和智力障碍领域的意义。三环类药物在惊恐障碍中的矛盾疗效引发了其低剂量时最终抗癫痫作用的问题。虽然有关于惊恐障碍标准脑电图的最新数据,但我们未找到任何与我们的研究类似的研究来对比我们的结果。