Dahlöf B
Department of Medicine, Ostra Hospital, Faculty of Medicine, University of Göteborg, Sweden.
Blood Press Suppl. 1992;6:1-75.
These studies were undertaken to evaluate different manifestations of structural cardiovascular changes and the effects of antihypertensive therapy in essential hypertension. A meta-analysis of 109 studies that had examined the effect of different pharmacological blood pressure lowering regimens on left ventricular structure, examined by echocardiography, was undertaken to increase the statistical power, to resolve uncertainty and to improve the accuracy of estimation of the magnitude of effect. Strict preset criteria were applied. The effect of different drugs in monotherapy and in particular first line antihypertensive therapies were compared, using an analysis of covariance (ANCOVA). ACE-inhibitors, beta-blockers and calcium antagonists all reduced left ventricular mass (LVM) through a reduction in wall hypertrophy, the effect being most pronounced with ACE-inhibitors. Conversely, diuretics reduced LVM mainly through a reduction of left ventricular volume. Previously untreated males (n = 28, 86 kg, 46 years, 27 kg/m2) with non-malignant essential hypertension (supine diastolic blood pressure (DBP) > 95 mmHg 3-4 times (in triplicate) on placebo) were randomized to long-term double-blind treatment with enalapril (E) or hydrochlorothiazide (H). There were no significant differences between the groups at baseline. Vascular alterations in the retina (eyeground photo, refined grading), cardiac morphology (M-mode echocardiography, ASE), structural vascular changes of the hand (plethysmography, minimal resistance (Rmin)), total peripheral resistance ((TPR), calculated from dye-dilution) and blood pressure (intraarterial) were significantly interrelated at baseline except LVM and Rmin. After 6 months of therapy, E reduced the signs of vascular changes in the retina as well as Rmin in the hand circulation, while H did not change or increased these structural vascular changes. The blood pressure lowering effect of E (mainly through lowering of TPR) tended to be more pronounced, measured both intraarterially and indirectly, than that seen with H (mainly through lowering of cardiac output), however, there were no significant differences. LVM decreased progressively with E while the effect of H was non-significant. E reduced wall thickness but not left ventricular diameter and also improved left ventricular distensibility significantly. The effect on cardiac morphology was significantly different between therapies when taking change in blood pressure into account. After the longest follow-up on monotherapy (18 months) E had reduced LVM by 2.7 g/mmHg and H (14 months) by 1.3 g/mmHg (significant for E only). In univariate analysis the changes in cardiovascular structure were significantly related to the changes in the Renin-Angiotensin-Aldosterone System (RAAS).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)
开展这些研究是为了评估原发性高血压患者心血管结构变化的不同表现以及降压治疗的效果。对109项研究进行荟萃分析,这些研究通过超声心动图检查了不同降压药物治疗方案对左心室结构的影响,以提高统计效力、解决不确定性并提高效应大小估计的准确性。应用了严格的预设标准。采用协方差分析(ANCOVA)比较了不同药物单药治疗的效果,尤其是一线降压治疗的效果。血管紧张素转换酶抑制剂(ACEI)、β受体阻滞剂和钙拮抗剂均通过减轻心室壁肥厚来降低左心室质量(LVM),其中ACEI的效果最为显著。相反,利尿剂主要通过减少左心室容积来降低LVM。将28例未经治疗的男性(体重86 kg,年龄46岁,体重指数27 kg/m²)非恶性原发性高血压患者(安慰剂治疗时仰卧位舒张压(DBP)>95 mmHg,测量3至4次(每次测量3次))随机分为依那普利(E)或氢氯噻嗪(H)长期双盲治疗组。两组在基线时无显著差异。视网膜血管改变(眼底照片,精细分级)、心脏形态(M型超声心动图,ASE)、手部血管结构改变(体积描记法,最小阻力(Rmin))、总外周阻力((TPR),由染料稀释法计算)和血压(动脉内测量)在基线时除LVM和Rmin外均显著相关。治疗6个月后,E组减轻了视网膜血管改变的体征以及手部循环中的Rmin,而H组未改变或加重了这些血管结构改变。E组的降压效果(主要通过降低TPR)在动脉内和间接测量时均比H组(主要通过降低心输出量)更显著,然而,差异无统计学意义。E组LVM逐渐降低,而H组效果不显著。E组降低了室壁厚度但未降低左心室直径,并且显著改善了左心室舒张性。考虑血压变化后,不同治疗对心脏形态的影响存在显著差异。单药治疗最长随访18个月后,E组LVM降低了2.7 g/mmHg,H组(随访14个月)降低了1.3 g/mmHg(仅E组差异有统计学意义)。单因素分析显示,心血管结构变化与肾素 - 血管紧张素 - 醛固酮系统(RAAS)的变化显著相关。(摘要截选至400字)