Moses S, Manji F, Bradley J E, Nagelkerke N J, Malisa M A, Plummer F A
Department of Community Health, University of Nairobi, Kenya.
Lancet. 1992 Aug 22;340(8817):463-6. doi: 10.1016/0140-6736(92)91778-7.
We investigated the impact of a short-lived policy of charging fees to patients attending public-sector outpatient health facilities in Kenya by collecting data on attendance at Nairobi's Special Treatment Clinic for sexually transmitted diseases (STDs) before (23 months), during (9 months), and after (15 months) the user-charge period. During the user-charge period, the seasonally adjusted total mean monthly attendance of men decreased significantly to 40% (95% CI 36-45) of that before fees were levied. Attendance rose in the post-user-charge period, but reached only 64% (59-68) of the pre-user-charge level. For women, the adjusted total mean monthly attendance during the user-charge period was reduced significantly to 65% (55-77) of the pre-user-charge level. Mean monthly attendance by women rose in the post-user-charge period to 22% (9-37) above the pre-user-charge level. There was no evidence of an increase in attendance over the course of the user-charge period among either men or women. The introduction of user fees probably increased the number of untreated STDs in the population, with potentially serious long-term health implications. The user-fee experience in Kenya should be carefully evaluated before similar measures are introduced elsewhere.
我们通过收集内罗毕性传播疾病(STD)特殊治疗诊所收费期之前(23个月)、期间(9个月)和之后(15个月)的就诊数据,调查了肯尼亚一项针对公立门诊医疗机构患者收取费用的短期政策的影响。在收费期内,经季节性调整后的男性每月总平均就诊人数显著下降至收费前的40%(95%置信区间36 - 45)。收费期后就诊人数有所上升,但仅达到收费前水平的64%(59 - 68)。对于女性而言,收费期内经调整后的每月总平均就诊人数显著降至收费前水平的65%(55 - 77)。收费期后女性每月平均就诊人数上升至比收费前水平高出22%(9 - 37)。在收费期内,无论是男性还是女性,均没有证据表明就诊人数增加。收取费用可能增加了人群中未经治疗的性传播疾病数量,对长期健康可能产生严重影响。在其他地方推行类似措施之前,应仔细评估肯尼亚收取费用的经验。