Waddington J L, Weller M P, Crow T J, Hirsch S R
Department of Clinical Pharmacology, Royal College of Surgeons, Ireland, Dublin.
Arch Gen Psychiatry. 1992 Dec;49(12):990-4. doi: 10.1001/archpsyc.1992.01820120078011.
A distinctive feature of these workshops, in addition to those noted in the introductory overview, is the selection of a relatively isolated location for a 1-week period. This, together with a rich and varied program and an ethos of informality, encourages participants to discuss not only the work presented but also their unpublished work and their intuitions based on preliminary data and analyses. Such an interchange is of inestimable value to the schizophrenia research community. In scientific terms, a panel of concluding discussants (Drs Kendell, Torrey, and Waddington) were in some measure of agreement that genetics, particularly molecular genetics, appears to be experiencing a period of retrenchment, while epidemiology is experiencing something of a renaissance. Maternal influenza was a prominent theme, although the data were far from consistent. It was argued by Dr Wessely that risk for schizophrenia putatively attributable to maternal influenza might be 5% to 10% of all cases, indicating a modest effect. Eclectically, Dr Kendell believed the effect to be "real" but slight and fragile, it being sought against large aggregates that almost inevitably result in differing findings from differing countries or from different data bases within a given country. Gender differences were also among the more prominent themes, not just in an epidemiologic context but also in a variety of other studies. This points anew to disturbances in schizophrenia of factors that regulate, or are intimately associated with, sexual dimorphism in brain development. Abnormalities in cerebral asymmetry continue to pervade a variety of research findings and point further to neurodevelopmental anomalies.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
除了在引言概述中提到的那些特点外,这些研讨会的一个显著特征是选择了一个相对偏远的地点,为期一周。这一点,再加上丰富多样的议程和不拘礼节的氛围,鼓励参与者不仅讨论已发表的研究成果,还讨论他们未发表的工作以及基于初步数据和分析得出的直觉。这种交流对精神分裂症研究界具有不可估量的价值。从科学角度来看,一组总结讨论者(肯德尔博士、托里博士和瓦丁顿博士)在一定程度上达成了共识,即遗传学,尤其是分子遗传学,似乎正处于一个收缩期,而流行病学正经历某种复兴。母亲感染流感是一个突出的主题,尽管数据远非一致。韦塞利博士认为,假定由母亲感染流感导致的精神分裂症风险可能占所有病例的5%至10%,这表明影响不大。综合来看,肯德尔博士认为这种影响是“真实的”,但微小且不稳定,因为是在大量数据中寻找这种影响,而这几乎不可避免地会导致不同国家或给定国家内不同数据库得出不同的结果。性别差异也是较为突出的主题之一,不仅在流行病学背景下如此,在其他各类研究中也是如此。这再次表明,精神分裂症中存在着调节大脑发育中性别二态性或与之密切相关的因素的紊乱。大脑不对称异常继续贯穿于各种研究结果中,进一步指向神经发育异常。(摘要截选至250字)