Willats J
Polytechnic of East London.
Child Dev. 1992 Jun;63(3):692-710.
Piaget has suggested that the reason why children find it difficult to draw foreshortened views is because they lack any conscious awareness of their own viewpoint. Instead, it is proposed that most of these difficulties derive from the constraints of drawing as a representational system: for example, although a round region shows a true view of a foreshortened stick, it is unsatisfactory as a representation. To test between these alternative proposals, 4-, 7-, and 12-year-olds were asked to draw sticks and discs in foreshortened and nonforeshortened positions. As predicted, fewer 7- and 12-year-olds used a round region to represent a foreshortened stick, compared with children of the same age who used a long region to represent a foreshortened disc. In addition, the 12-year-olds used a different and more effective denotation system compared with the 7-year-olds.
皮亚杰认为,儿童觉得绘制缩短视图困难的原因在于他们缺乏对自身视角的任何有意识的认知。相反,有人提出,这些困难大多源于绘画作为一种表征系统的限制:例如,尽管一个圆形区域展示了缩短的棍子的真实视图,但作为一种表征却不尽人意。为了在这些不同的提议之间进行检验,研究人员要求4岁、7岁和12岁的儿童绘制处于缩短和非缩短位置的棍子和圆盘。正如预期的那样,与使用长形区域来表示缩短圆盘的同龄儿童相比,较少有7岁和12岁的儿童使用圆形区域来表示缩短的棍子。此外,与7岁儿童相比,12岁儿童使用了一种不同且更有效的表示系统。