Maier B, Gerber U, König M, Stetter G
Institut für Radiologie und Nuklearmedizin, Ruhr-Universität Bochum im Knappschaftskrankenhaus Bochum-Langendreer.
Radiologe. 1992 Aug;32(8):393-6.
Within the frame work of lumbar myelography, 158 patients were entered in a double-blind study in order to test a dimeric contrast medium (iotrolan) against a monomeric one (iopamidol), both of them non-ionic. A three-step scheme was applied to evaluate the X-ray pictures with respect to contrast quality. Particular attention was paid to the visibility of details, i.e. the nerve root and its course, as well as to how well it could be distinguished in the nerve root sheath. On the basis of a high level of significance (P less than 0.05), comparison of the two contrast media showed no difference in contrast quality. Sixty-nine percent of the examinations using iotrolan resulted in excellent contrast quality, whereas the corresponding very good results using iopamidol lay at 76%. Twenty-nine percent of the patients examined with iotrolan and 27% of those examined with iopamidol showed side effects. Headache occurred most frequently, followed by nausea, dizziness and neck pain. Sixty percent of the patients suffering from postmyelographic reactions reported delayed headache, which occurred most often with iotrolan rather than iopamidol. As for manifestation of other postmyelographic side effects, there were no significant differences (P less than 0.05, Fischer's test) between the two groups of contrast media.
在腰椎脊髓造影的框架内,158名患者参与了一项双盲研究,以测试一种二聚体造影剂(碘曲仑)与一种单体造影剂(碘帕醇)的效果,二者均为非离子型。采用三步方案评估X线片的造影质量。特别关注细节的可见性,即神经根及其走行,以及在神经根鞘内的辨识度。基于高度显著性(P小于0.05),两种造影剂的造影质量比较无差异。使用碘曲仑的检查中69%造影质量极佳,而使用碘帕醇的相应良好结果为76%。使用碘曲仑检查的患者中有29%出现副作用,使用碘帕醇检查的患者中有27%出现副作用。头痛最为常见,其次是恶心、头晕和颈部疼痛。60%发生脊髓造影后反应的患者出现延迟性头痛,碘曲仑引发的情况比碘帕醇更常见。至于其他脊髓造影后副作用的表现,两组造影剂之间无显著差异(P小于0.05,费舍尔检验)。