Redegeld F A, Chatterjee S, Berger N A, Sitkovsky M V
Laboratory of Immunology, National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD 20892.
J Immunol. 1992 Dec 1;149(11):3509-16.
We hypothesized that CTL-induced target cell (TC) death is partially due to processes that follow the DNA damage in target cells and include the activation of poly-ADP-ribose transferase (PADPRT) by DNA strand breaks. According to this model, the activated PADPRT is expected to deplete NAD, ATP, and to contribute to the TC death. We used inhibitors of PADPRT and a PADPRT-deficient cell mutant, as well as other nucleated TC and SRBC to test the role of PADPRT in CTL-induced cytotoxicity. It is found that inhibitors of PADPRT (3-aminobenzamide, benzamide (aromatic amides)) and nicotinamide all inhibit the CTL-mediated lysis of both Ag-specific TC and of Ag-nonbearing TC. The effect of PADPRT inhibitors was not due to inhibition of the lethal hit delivery by CTL, because in parallel control experiments, the same inhibitors did not interfere with CTL-induced lysis of SRBC, cells that are devoid of nuclei and PADPRT. Moreover, the effect of inhibitors of PADPRT did not affect earlier stages of lethal hit delivery because 3-aminobenzamide and benzamide did not interfere with CTL-induced DNA fragmentation in TC at concentration which protected TC lysis. Importantly, a PADPRT-deficient cell line was also much more resistant to CTL-induced lysis as tested in retargeting (4 and 8 h) assays; this was expected if activation of PADPRT is indeed involved in TC death. Control experiments reveal that the relative resistance of the PADPRT-deficient cell mutant to CTL-induced lysis was not related to its impaired ability to form conjugates and to trigger CTL (as tested in granule exocytosis assay). In addition, PADPRT-deficient cells were as susceptible to CTL-induced DNA fragmentation as were the control cells; yet, they were resistant to CTL-induced 51Cr-release. Control cells and PADPRT-deficient mutant were equally susceptible to antibody+C'-mediated lysis. Our data support the view that the activation of PADPRT can contribute to the CTL-induced cytolysis of some TC, but is not involved in lysis of other TC, as evidenced by the ability of CTL to efficiently lyse SRBC. These data suggest that there could be multiple molecular pathways of TC death in CTL-mediated cytotoxicity and the relative contribution of PADPRT and/or other enzymes will reflect the individual make-up of a particular TC.
我们推测,细胞毒性T淋巴细胞(CTL)诱导的靶细胞(TC)死亡部分归因于靶细胞DNA损伤后发生的一系列过程,其中包括DNA链断裂激活多聚ADP - 核糖转移酶(PADPRT)。根据这一模型,活化的PADPRT预期会消耗烟酰胺腺嘌呤二核苷酸(NAD)、三磷酸腺苷(ATP),并促使TC死亡。我们使用了PADPRT抑制剂、PADPRT缺陷型细胞突变体,以及其他有核TC和绵羊红细胞(SRBC)来测试PADPRT在CTL诱导的细胞毒性中的作用。结果发现,PADPRT抑制剂(3 - 氨基苯甲酰胺、苯甲酰胺(芳香酰胺))和烟酰胺均能抑制CTL介导的抗原特异性TC和无抗原TC的裂解。PADPRT抑制剂的作用并非源于抑制CTL传递致死性打击,因为在平行对照实验中,相同的抑制剂并未干扰CTL诱导的SRBC裂解,SRBC是无细胞核和PADPRT的细胞。此外,PADPRT抑制剂的作用并未影响致死性打击传递的早期阶段,因为3 - 氨基苯甲酰胺和苯甲酰胺在保护TC裂解的浓度下,并未干扰CTL诱导的TC中的DNA片段化。重要的是,在重定向(4小时和8小时)实验中测试发现,PADPRT缺陷型细胞系对CTL诱导的裂解也具有更强的抗性;如果PADPRT的激活确实参与了TC死亡,那么这一结果是可以预期的。对照实验表明,PADPRT缺陷型细胞突变体对CTL诱导裂解的相对抗性与其形成结合物和触发CTL的能力受损无关(如在颗粒胞吐实验中测试)。此外,PADPRT缺陷型细胞与对照细胞一样易受CTL诱导的DNA片段化影响;然而,它们对CTL诱导的51铬释放具有抗性。对照细胞和PADPRT缺陷型突变体对抗体 + 补体介导的裂解同样敏感。我们的数据支持这样一种观点,即PADPRT的激活可导致CTL诱导的某些TC细胞溶解,但不参与其他TC的裂解,这一点由CTL有效裂解SRBC的能力得以证明。这些数据表明,在CTL介导的细胞毒性中,TC死亡可能存在多种分子途径,并且PADPRT和/或其他酶的相对作用将反映特定TC的个体组成。