O'Connor Deborah L, Jacobs Joan, Hall Robert, Adamkin David, Auestad Nancy, Castillo Marcella, Connor William E, Connor Sonja L, Fitzgerald Kathleen, Groh-Wargo Sharon, Hartmann E Eugenie, Janowsky Jeri, Lucas Alan, Margeson Dean, Mena Patricia, Neuringer Martha, Ross Gail, Singer Lynn, Stephenson Terence, Szabo Joanne, Zemon Vance
Department of Nutritional Sciences, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada. Deborah_l.o'
J Pediatr Gastroenterol Nutr. 2003 Oct;37(4):437-46. doi: 10.1097/00005176-200310000-00008.
In a recent meta-analysis, human milk feeding of low birth-weight (LBW) infants was associated with a 5.2 point improvement in IQ tests. However, in the studies in this meta-analysis, feeding regimens were used (unfortified human milk, term formula) that no longer represent recommended practice.
To compare the growth, in-hospital feeding tolerance, morbidity, and development (cognitive, motor, visual, and language) of LBW infants fed different amounts of human milk until term chronologic age (CA) with those of LBW infants fed nutrient-enriched formulas from first enteral feeding.
The data in this study were collected in a previous randomized controlled trial assessing the benefit of supplementing nutrient-enriched formulas for LBW infants with arachidonic acid and docosahexaenoic acid. Infants (n = 463, birth weight, 750-1,800 g) were enrolled from nurseries located in Chile, the United Kingdom, and the United States. If human milk was fed before hospital discharge, it was fortified (3,050-3,300 kJ/L, 22-24 kcal/oz). As infants were weaned from human milk, they were fed nutrient-enriched formula with or without arachidonic and docosahexaenoic acids (3,300 kJ/L before term, 3,050 kJ/L thereafter) until 12 months CA. Formula fed infants were given nutrient-enriched formula with or without added arachidonic and docosahexaenoic acids (3,300 kJ/L to term, 3,050 kJ/L thereafter) until 12 months CA. For the purposes of this evaluation, infants were categorized into four mutually exclusive feeding groups: 1) predominantly human milk fed until term CA (PHM-T, n = 43); 2) >/= 50% energy from human milk before hospital discharge (>/= 50% HM, n = 98); 3) < 50% of energy from human milk before hospital discharge (< 50% HM, n = 203); or 4) predominantly formula fed until term CA (PFF-T, n = 119).
PFF-T infants weighed approximately 500 g more at term CA than did PHM-T infants. This absolute difference persisted until 6 months CA. PFF-T infants were also longer (1.0-1.5 cm) and had larger head circumferences (0.3-1.1 cm) than both PHM-T and >/= 50% HM infants at term CA. There was a positive association between duration of human milk feeding and the Bayley Mental Index at 12 months CA (P = 0.032 full and P = 0.073 reduced, statistical models) after controlling for the confounding variables of home environment and maternal intelligence. Infants with chronic lung disease fed >/= 50% HM until term CA (n = 22) had a mean Bayley Motor Index about 11 points higher at 12 months CA compared with infants PFF-T (n = 24, P = 0.033 full model).
Our data suggest that, despite a slower early growth rate, human milk fed LBW infants have development at least comparable to that of infants fed nutrient-enriched formula. Exploratory analysis suggests that some subgroups of human milk fed LBW infants may have enhanced development, although this needs to be confirmed in future studies.
在最近的一项荟萃分析中,低出生体重(LBW)婴儿母乳喂养与智商测试成绩提高5.2分相关。然而,在该荟萃分析中的研究里,所采用的喂养方案(未强化的母乳、足月儿配方奶)已不再是推荐做法。
比较不同母乳喂养量直至足月实足年龄(CA)的LBW婴儿与从首次肠内喂养就开始喂食营养强化配方奶的LBW婴儿在生长、住院期间喂养耐受性、发病率及发育(认知、运动、视觉和语言)方面的差异。
本研究的数据收集自之前一项随机对照试验,该试验评估了为LBW婴儿补充富含花生四烯酸和二十二碳六烯酸的营养强化配方奶的益处。婴儿(n = 463,出生体重750 - 1800 g)来自智利、英国和美国的多家托儿所。如果在出院前喂母乳,则进行强化(3050 - 3300 kJ/L,22 - 24 kcal/盎司)。当婴儿从母乳断奶后,他们被喂食含或不含花生四烯酸和二十二碳六烯酸的营养强化配方奶(足月前3300 kJ/L,之后3050 kJ/L)直至12个月实足年龄。配方奶喂养的婴儿被给予含或不含添加花生四烯酸和二十二碳六烯酸的营养强化配方奶(足月前3300 kJ/L,之后3050 kJ/L)直至12个月实足年龄。为了本评估目的,婴儿被分为四个相互排斥的喂养组:1)直至足月实足年龄主要母乳喂养(PHM - T,n = 43);2)出院前母乳提供能量≥50%(≥50% HM,n = 98);3)出院前母乳提供能量<50%(<50% HM,n = 203);或4)直至足月实足年龄主要配方奶喂养(PFF - T,n = 119)。
足月实足年龄时,PFF - T组婴儿比PHM - T组婴儿重约500 g。这一绝对差异持续到6个月实足年龄。足月实足年龄时,PFF - T组婴儿也比PHM - T组和≥50% HM组婴儿更高(1.0 - 1.5 cm),头围更大(0.3 - 1.1 cm)。在控制了家庭环境和母亲智力等混杂变量后,母乳喂养持续时间与12个月实足年龄时的贝利智力指数之间存在正相关(完整统计模型P = 0.032,简化统计模型P = 0.073)。直至足月实足年龄时,慢性肺病婴儿中母乳提供能量≥50%(n = 22)组在12个月实足年龄时的平均贝利运动指数比PFF - T组婴儿(n = 24,完整模型P = 0.033)高约11分。
我们的数据表明,尽管早期生长速度较慢,但母乳喂养的LBW婴儿的发育至少与喂食营养强化配方奶的婴儿相当。探索性分析表明,母乳喂养的LBW婴儿的一些亚组可能发育更好,尽管这需要在未来研究中得到证实。