Kuo H-C
Department of Urology, Buddhist Tzu Chi General Hospital, Hualien, Taiwan.
BJU Int. 2003 Oct;92(6):597-601. doi: 10.1046/j.1464-410x.2003.04441.x.
To investigate the therapeutic effect of resiniferatoxin in patients with chronic spinal cord lesions, as detrusor hyper-reflexia and external sphincter dyssynergia (DESD) are common phenomenon in such patients.
Twenty patients with chronic spinal cord lesions and DESD refractory to anticholinergic treatment were enrolled in a prospective study. They were treated with 30 mL of 10 micro mol/L resiniferatoxin for 30 min. Four types of response were recorded during instillation: type 1, a sustained high-pressure detrusor contraction followed by complete acontractility; type 2, a high-pressure contraction followed by progressively lower contractions; type 3, intermittent high-pressure detrusor contractions throughout the instillation; type 4, intermittent low-pressure detrusor contractions. The changes in clinical symptoms and urodynamics at baseline, during resiniferatoxin instillation and 1 month after treatment were compared.
All patients had DESD and 10 had autonomic dysreflexia; 18 had urinary incontinence and 13 had difficult urination. Continence and/or difficult urination improved in 12 patients, including all five with type 1, four with type 2, two with type 3 and only one with a type 4 response. Four patients became dry during the day and eight had less urgency and fewer incontinence episodes, and a significantly increased voided volume. Of the 13 patients who complained of difficult urination, eight had an improvement either by spontaneous voiding (five) or the Crede manoeuvre to voiding (three). The mean (sd) maximum cystometric capacity increased significantly after treatment, from 102.1 (31.5) to 236.6 (88.6) mL (P < 0.001), but the detrusor pressure showed no significant change, at 55.9 (23.2) to 47.5 (28.1) cmH2O. The external urethral sphincter showed intermittent activity during reflexic detrusor contractions at baseline.
Resiniferatoxin at 10 micro mol/L has a clinical effect on two-thirds of patients with a spinal cord lesion and detrusor hyper-reflexia, but not on the DESD. The initial response to resiniferatoxin instillation might predict a favourable therapeutic outcome.
鉴于逼尿肌反射亢进和外括约肌协同失调(DESD)在慢性脊髓损伤患者中较为常见,研究树脂毒素对这类患者的治疗效果。
20例慢性脊髓损伤且抗胆碱能治疗无效的DESD患者纳入一项前瞻性研究。他们接受30 mL 10微摩尔/升的树脂毒素治疗30分钟。灌注期间记录四种反应类型:1型,持续性高压逼尿肌收缩后完全无收缩;2型,高压收缩后收缩逐渐减弱;3型,灌注期间间歇性高压逼尿肌收缩;4型,间歇性低压逼尿肌收缩。比较基线时、树脂毒素灌注期间及治疗后1个月临床症状和尿动力学的变化。
所有患者均有DESD,10例有自主神经反射异常;18例有尿失禁,13例排尿困难。12例患者的尿失禁和/或排尿困难得到改善,包括所有5例1型反应患者、4例2型反应患者、2例3型反应患者和仅1例4型反应患者。4例患者白天不再尿湿,8例患者尿急减轻且尿失禁发作减少,排尿量显著增加。在13例主诉排尿困难的患者中,8例通过自主排尿(5例)或采用克里德手法排尿(3例)得到改善。治疗后平均(标准差)最大膀胱测压容量显著增加,从102.1(31.5)毫升增至236.6(88.6)毫升(P<0.001),但逼尿肌压力无显著变化,从55.9(23.2)厘米水柱降至47.5(28.1)厘米水柱。基线时,在反射性逼尿肌收缩期间,尿道外括约肌表现为间歇性活动。
10微摩尔/升的树脂毒素对三分之二的脊髓损伤和逼尿肌反射亢进患者有临床效果,但对DESD无效。树脂毒素灌注的初始反应可能预示良好的治疗结果。