Stekol'nikov A A
Zoological Institute of RAS, 199034 Saint-Petersburg, Universitetskaya nab., 1, Russia.
Zh Obshch Biol. 2003 Jul-Aug;64(4):357-68.
A possibility to put a question of truth of knowledge in biological systematics is studied. It is shown that the problem of truth in reference to systematics is wider than a question of classified information reliability. Prerequisites needed for logically accurate formulation of a definition and criteria of truth are considered. It is shown that such prerequisites are present in taxonomic practice, namely in a process of diagnosis compiling. Philosophical analysis of this work has been carried out. Interpretation of an essence of systematics as classification is connected with use of classical concept of truth (which defines truth as correspondence between knowledge and object) in its undeveloped form. Carried analysis allows supposing that a theory of systematics based on diagnostics rather than on classification would be more prospective. Use of imperfect concept of truth can be seen also in notions that system of taxa must reflect its evolutionary history. Development and modernization of Aristotle's orientation to discovery of the object form can become an alternative to such opinions. An aspiration to achieve the truth is the main motive of systematic work. An influence of this aspiration on a selection of purposes of taxonomic work and theoretical comprehension of its bases is shown. Such features of modern biological systematics as its accessibility for new results, criticism in respect of external morphological characters, and interest in intraspecific variability are connected with this aspiration. This motive comes into contradiction with a tendency to withdraw the problem of truth as such, which takes place in some brunches of theoretic systematics.
研究了在生物系统学中提出知识真实性问题的可能性。结果表明,系统学中真理问题比分类信息可靠性问题更为宽泛。考虑了逻辑精确表述真理定义和标准所需的前提条件。结果表明,这些前提条件存在于分类学实践中,即在编制诊断的过程中。对这项工作进行了哲学分析。将系统学本质解释为分类与以未发展形式使用经典真理概念(将真理定义为知识与对象之间的对应)相关联。所进行的分析表明,基于诊断而非分类的系统学理论可能更具前瞻性。在关于分类单元系统必须反映其进化历史的观念中也可以看到对不完善真理概念的使用。亚里士多德对发现对象形式的取向的发展和现代化可以成为此类观点的替代方案。追求真理是系统学工作的主要动机。展示了这种追求对分类学工作目的选择及其基础的理论理解的影响。现代生物系统学的这些特征,如对新结果的可及性、对外部形态特征的批判以及对种内变异性的兴趣,都与这种追求相关。这种动机与在理论系统学的某些分支中出现的回避真理问题本身的趋势相矛盾。