Chandra Sujata, Crane Joan, Hutchens Donna, Bennett Kelly, O'Grady Terry, Duff Ann, Macgregor David
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Memorial University of Newfoundland, St. John's, NL, Canada.
J Obstet Gynaecol Can. 2003 Oct;25(10):825-9. doi: 10.1016/s1701-2163(16)30672-7.
To compare the utilization of the second trimester maternal serum screen (MSS) of a-fetoprotein, human chorionic gonadotrophin, and unconjugated estriol, in Newfoundland, by practice location, training, and gender.
Four hundred eighteen anonymous self-reported questionnaires were mailed out to all practising family physicians, general practitioners, and obstetricians in Newfoundland, who were identified through the provincial medical board. The survey included questions on demographic characteristics, provision of antenatal care, gestational age at which MSS is ordered, reasons for offering or not offering MSS, and the use of routine antenatal ultrasound. Categorical data were analyzed using chi-square and Fisher exact tests, as appropriate.
Overall, 63% of physicians responded to the survey. Forty percent of respondents had an urban practice. Female physicians, regardless of specialty, were more likely to offer MSS to their patients (89% vs. 78%; P = 0.04), whereas family physicians and obstetricians were more likely to offer screening than general practitioners (85% vs. 83% vs. 25%; P = 0.02). Among physicians offering MSS, 54% offered it only to women 35 years and older. Practice location did not affect whether a woman was offered MSS (P = 0.41). Twenty-five percent of family physicians offering MSS did not offer it at the appropriate gestational age of 15 to 20 weeks. Ninety-four percent of pregnant women were routinely offered an ultrasound during pregnancy.
The utilization of MSS in Newfoundland is affected by physician training and gender, but not by practice location. Further education of physicians is required to ensure appropriate use and timing of this screening test.
按执业地点、培训情况和性别比较纽芬兰孕中期母血清筛查(MSS)中α-甲胎蛋白、人绒毛膜促性腺激素和未结合雌三醇的使用情况。
向通过省级医学委员会识别出的纽芬兰所有执业家庭医生、全科医生和产科医生邮寄了418份匿名自填式问卷。调查包括有关人口统计学特征、提供产前护理、开出MSS检查的孕周、提供或不提供MSS检查的原因以及常规产前超声使用情况的问题。分类数据在适当情况下使用卡方检验和Fisher精确检验进行分析。
总体而言,63%的医生回复了调查。40%的受访者在城市执业。无论专科如何,女医生更有可能为患者提供MSS检查(89%对78%;P = 0.04),而家庭医生和产科医生比全科医生更有可能提供筛查(85%对83%对25%;P = 0.02)。在提供MSS检查的医生中,54%仅向35岁及以上的女性提供。执业地点并未影响女性是否接受MSS检查(P = 0.41)。提供MSS检查的家庭医生中有25%未在15至20周的适当孕周提供该检查。94%的孕妇在孕期接受了常规超声检查。
纽芬兰MSS的使用受医生培训和性别的影响,但不受执业地点的影响。需要对医生进行进一步教育,以确保该筛查试验的正确使用和时机。