Smith J B, Cowchock F S, Lata J A, Hankinson B T
Department of Medicine, Jefferson Medical College, Thomas Jefferson University, Philadelphia, PA 19107.
J Reprod Immunol. 1992 Oct;22(3):217-24. doi: 10.1016/0165-0378(92)90044-5.
One hundred and sixty-eight women were immunized on a single occasion with paternal mononuclear cells (MNC) for recurrent spontaneous abortion (RSA) and pregnancy outcomes were analysed with respect to the number of MNC given. The study was done in a prospective sequential fashion using all MNC recoverable from a unit of the spouse's blood and both patients and investigators were blinded as to the number of cells injected. Women receiving low and mid-range doses of MNC (58-305 x 10(6) and 308-567 x 10(6), respectively) had a significantly higher pregnancy success rate (57%) than those receiving the high (568-2677 x 10(6)) dose of MNC (41%). In 77 consecutive patients the diameter of the largest immediate skin flare reaction at the site of subcutaneous injection was recorded. No correlation was found between the skin flare response and the number of MNC injected. Our data suggest that a blinded trial of paternal MNC immunization comparing what appears to be optimum numbers of cells (100-550 million) to a low dose inoculum (e.g., 10 million), again noting the sizes of the skin flare reactions, might answer questions about efficacy and placebo effects of immunotherapy for RSA.
168名女性单次接受父系单核细胞(MNC)免疫以治疗复发性自然流产(RSA),并根据给予的MNC数量分析妊娠结局。该研究以前瞻性序贯方式进行,使用从配偶单位血液中可回收的所有MNC,患者和研究人员均对注射的细胞数量不知情。接受低剂量和中等剂量MNC(分别为58 - 305×10⁶和308 - 567×10⁶)的女性妊娠成功率(57%)显著高于接受高剂量(568 - 2677×10⁶)MNC的女性(41%)。记录了77例连续患者皮下注射部位最大即时皮肤潮红反应的直径。未发现皮肤潮红反应与注射的MNC数量之间存在相关性。我们的数据表明,一项对父系MNC免疫进行的盲法试验,将看似最佳数量的细胞(1亿 - 5.5亿)与低剂量接种物(例如1000万)进行比较,同时再次记录皮肤潮红反应的大小,可能会回答关于RSA免疫治疗的疗效和安慰剂效应的问题。