Serena A, Nogueiras J M, Outomuro J, Ortega A, Corredera E, Romero J, Del Campo V, Campos L M
Servicio de Medicina Nuclear, Hospital do Meixoeiro, Vigo, Pontevedra.
Rev Esp Med Nucl. 2003 Sep-Oct;22(5):327-35. doi: 10.1016/s0212-6982(03)72209-5.
To compare the diagnostic yield of CT scan and perfusion SPECT on admission and its prognostic value in clinical outcome.
25 ischemic stroke cases were studied on admission (<24 h) and at 30-60 days by CT scan, 99mTc-HMPAO-SPECT and neurological scales. Infarct size and severity on SPECT were assessed: visually "Total Weighted Score," added value in 22 areas, and by several semiquantitative count-based indices.
Sensitivity: the first CT scan was positive in 24% patients, initial SPECT in 75% (73% of pure subcortical infarcts and 91% of those with cortical involvement). Localization: kappa: 0.725 between SPECT findings on admission and those in control-CT at 5 days. Extent and severity: correlations between count-based and visual indices (r: >0.719), the latter correlated slightly better with clinical scales. Both predicted similarly (Rho>0.739) infarct size in CT diagnostic scan. Early Outcome: There were statistical differences between deceased and survivors in SPECT (<24h) indices and CT-infarct size (mean 5 days), but not in neurological scores on admission. Long term Outcome: Correlation of initial SPECT indices with follow-up functional scores (SNSLP, Barthel index; mean 37 days) was only significant for visual SPECT indices (Rho:0.560 to 0.620). Nevertheless the best predictor of functional status on discharge was the Barthel Index on admission.
比较CT扫描和灌注单光子发射计算机断层扫描(SPECT)在入院时的诊断率及其对临床结局的预后价值。
对25例缺血性中风患者在入院时(<24小时)以及30 - 60天时进行CT扫描、99mTc - HMPAO - SPECT检查及神经功能量表评估。通过视觉评估SPECT上梗死灶的大小和严重程度:“总加权评分”、22个区域的增加值,并采用几种基于计数的半定量指标。
敏感性:首次CT扫描在24%的患者中呈阳性,初始SPECT在75%的患者中呈阳性(73%的单纯皮质下梗死和91%有皮质受累的梗死)。定位:入院时SPECT结果与5天时对照CT结果之间的kappa值为0.725。范围和严重程度:基于计数的指标与视觉指标之间存在相关性(r:>0.719),后者与临床量表的相关性稍好。两者对CT诊断扫描中的梗死灶大小预测相似(Rho>0.739)。早期结局:死亡患者与存活患者在SPECT(<24小时)指标和CT梗死灶大小(平均5天)方面存在统计学差异,但入院时神经功能评分无差异。长期结局:初始SPECT指标与随访功能评分(SNSLP、Barthel指数;平均37天)的相关性仅在视觉SPECT指标方面显著(Rho:0.560至0.620)。然而,出院时功能状态的最佳预测指标是入院时的Barthel指数。
1)早期SPECT具有良好的敏感性和准确的梗死灶大小预测能力,因此可作为决定溶栓治疗的有用工具;2)视觉评分与更复杂的指标表现相当;3)梗死体积似乎是重要结局的关键决定因素;其他因素(如位置等)可能影响长期功能状态。