Peterson Linda R, Schechtman Kenneth B, Ewald Gregory A, Geltman Edward M, de las Fuentes Lisa, Meyer Timothy, Krekeler Pamela, Moore Martha L, Rogers Joseph G
Cardiovascular Division, Washington University School of Medicine, Campus Box 8086, 660 S. Euclid Avenue, St. Louis, MO 63110, USA.
J Heart Lung Transplant. 2003 Oct;22(10):1141-8. doi: 10.1016/s1053-2498(02)01225-1.
Previous work shows that patients with heart failure patients who have peak oxygen consumption (VO2 peak) >14 ml/kg/min do not derive a survival benefit from cardiac transplantation. However, this was shown before beta-blocker therapy for patients with systolic heart failure became common, and beta-blockers improve survival in patients with heart failure without changing VO(2) peak. Our purpose was to re-evaluate the utility of VO(2) peak >14 ml/kg/min as an indicator of the need for cardiac transplantation in patients with heart failure who are taking beta-blockers.
Actuarial, hemodynamic, and exercise ventilatory data were collected from 540 patients with heart failure, 256 of whom were taking beta-blockers. We tracked death and cardiac transplantation. We stratified the percentage of patients event-free 1 and 3 years after VO(2) peak study by their VO(2) peak and beta-blocker status, and compared 1- and 3-year post-transplant survival (United Network of Organ Sharing [UNOS] data). We also compared total mortality for the patients with heart failure as stratified by beta-blocker stats and VO(2) peak (excluding the 42 who underwent transplantation) with UNOS post-transplant survival.
Patients with heart failure who were receiving beta-blockers and whose VO(2) peak was > or =12 ml/kg/min had greater 1- and 3-year event-free survival rates (95% confidence intervals, 92.6%-96.6% and 85.8%-96.0%) than did post-transplant patients (83.9%-86.3% and 75.4%-76.6%). However, in patients with heart failure not taking beta-blockers, VO(2) peak <14 ml/kg/min was associated with worse 3-year survival (38.9 - 62.1%) than that for post-transplant patients. Excluding the 42 patients with heart failure in our study who underwent transplantation and then evaluating survival of the remaining patients with heart failure (not event-free survival) did not substantially change these results.
Patients with heart failure who are receiving beta-blockers do not derive a survival advantage at 1 and 3 years after cardiac transplantation if VO(2) peak is > or =12 ml/kg/min. Patients not taking beta-blockers whose VO(2) peak is <14 ml/kg/min have superior survival with cardiac transplantation.
