Van Harrison R, Janz Nancy K, Wolfe Robert A, Tedeschi Philip J, Stross Jeoffrey K, Huang Xuelin, McMahon Laurence F
Department of Medical Education, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48109, USA.
Cancer. 2003 Nov 1;98(9):1811-21. doi: 10.1002/cncr.11744.
Mammography screening rates are below national recommendations for older women. Understanding the relation between the characteristics of primary care physicians (PCPs) and mammography rates for older women can help to target screening improvement efforts.
Subjects were 2527 PCPs practicing in Michigan between 1997 and 1998. A cross-sectional design used Medicare data to identify women age 68 years or older in 1998 whom PCPs treated in 1997-1998 and to determine whether these women had a mammogram between 1996 and 1998. Eligible women were Medicare beneficiaries age 65 years or older by 1996, residing in Michigan from 1996 to 1998, without specified comorbidities likely to affect decisions regarding mammography. Correlations and multiple regressions examined the relation between this score and characteristics of both PCPs and their practice populations of older women.
Mammography rates across physicians' practices ranged from 3-100% (mean = 59%, standard deviation = 17%). Five predictors accounted for 55% of the variance in mammography rates across practices. Higher mammography rates were found to be independently related to physicians who have: a lower mean age for female Medicare patients, a higher mean number of physicians billing for patients' care, a lower mean number of inpatient admissions, obstetrics/gynecology practices, and a higher mean education level in patient's zip code (beta weights >/= 0.25, P < 0.0001).
PCPs vary substantially with regard to mammography rates for older women. Mammography rates vary more with the population of patients in physicians' practices than with commonly measured personal characteristics of physicians. Mammography rates should be adjusted for patient population to target individual PCPs with low mammography rates for interventions.
老年女性的乳房X光筛查率低于国家建议水平。了解初级保健医生(PCP)的特征与老年女性乳房X光检查率之间的关系有助于针对性地改进筛查工作。
研究对象为1997年至1998年在密歇根州执业的2527名初级保健医生。采用横断面设计,利用医疗保险数据确定1998年68岁及以上、在1997 - 1998年接受初级保健医生治疗的女性,并确定这些女性在1996年至1998年期间是否进行过乳房X光检查。符合条件的女性为1996年时年龄在65岁及以上、1996年至1998年居住在密歇根州、无可能影响乳房X光检查决策的特定合并症的医疗保险受益人。相关性分析和多元回归分析研究了该评分与初级保健医生及其老年女性患者群体特征之间的关系。
医生诊所的乳房X光检查率在3%至100%之间(平均 = 59%,标准差 = 17%)。五个预测因素占各诊所乳房X光检查率方差的55%。研究发现,较高的乳房X光检查率与以下医生独立相关:女性医疗保险患者平均年龄较低、为患者护理计费的医生平均人数较多、住院平均人数较低、妇产科诊所,以及患者邮政编码地区平均教育水平较高(β权重≥0.25,P < 0.0001)。
初级保健医生在老年女性乳房X光检查率方面差异很大。乳房X光检查率随医生诊所患者群体的变化比随医生常见的个人特征变化更大。应根据患者群体调整乳房X光检查率,以针对乳房X光检查率低的个体初级保健医生进行干预。