[脑脊液中无寡克隆带的多发性硬化症患者脑部的磁共振成像结果]
[Magnetic resonance findings in the brain of patients with multiple sclerosis without oligoclonal bands in the cerebrospinal fluid].
作者信息
Mesaroc Sarlota, Drulović Jelena, Lević Zvonimir, Perić Vesna
机构信息
Institute of Neurology, Clinical Center of Serbia, Belgrade.
出版信息
Srp Arh Celok Lek. 2003 Jan-Feb;131(1-2):31-5. doi: 10.2298/sarh0302031m.
Locally produced oligoclonal IgG bands (OCB) are present in the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) of 95% patients with multiple sclerosis (MS) [2,3]. The most sensitive method for the detection of OCB is isoelectric focusing (IEF) [1]. Occasional patients with clinically definite MS lack evidence for intrathecal IgG synthesis [2,9]. This study was designed to compare brain magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) findings between CSF OCB positive and negative MS patients. The study comprised 22 OB negative patients with clinically definite MS and 22 OCB positive controls matched for age, disease duration, activity and course of MS. In the both groups clinical assessment was performed by using Expanded Disability Status Scale (EDSS) score. T2 weighted MRI of the brain was performed on a Siemens Magnetom (1.0T). Lesions were counted and sized for 15 anatomically defined locations: 7 periventricular (PV) and 8 non-periventricular (NPV) regions. An arbitrary scoring system weighted for lesions size was used to estimate total and regional lesions loads: a) 1 point was given for each lesion with a diameter 1-5 mm, b) 2 points for one lesion with a diameter 6-10 mm, c) 3 points for one over 10 mm, and confluent lesions scored one extra point [16]. Atrophy were scored as follows: 0-normal size, 1-mild atrophy, 2-moderate atrophy and 3-severe atrophy. Mean score of total brain MRI loads was lower in OCB negative than in OCB positive MS patients (44 vs. 50) but the difference was not statistically significant. Mean periventricular (32 vs. 23), non-periventricular (26 vs. 19) and infratentorial (11 vs. 9) scores were higher in OCB positive MS group in comparison with OCB negative patients, but non-significant (figure 1). There was no correlation between EDSS score and total MRI lesions load in OCB negative MS patients, while in OCB positive group we detected significant correlation between EDSS score and total MRI lesions load (p = 0.026) (figure 2). The results of this study demonstrate that by using conventional brain MRI the extent end severity of the pathological process seems to be similar in OCB negative and OCB positive MS patients. On the other hand, we found statistically significant correlation between brain MRI total lesion load and EDSS in the OCB positive MS patients, while this correlation was not detected in OCB negative MS patients. Differences in brain MRI findings between OCB positive nad OCB negative MS patients have been already analyzed [9,12]. In the first, Zeman et al. reported that OCB negative MS patients have lower total MRI brain lesion loads in comparison to OCB positive group, but the differences was not statistically significant [9]. In accordance with these findings, Fukazawa et al. also failed to show differences in the distribution, extent, shape and number of brain MRI lesions between OCB positive and negative MS patients. [12]. On the other hand, it has been demonstrated that the rate of intrathecal IgG synthesis apparently correlates with plaque volume in the brain, as demonstrated on MRI, in MS patients [17]. However, our results along with those from two above-mentioned previous studies do not support this notion. In conclusion, trend towards lesser MRI lesion load and lack of its correlation with EDSS in OCB negative MS patients, warrants further investigations with new MRI techniques (magnetic resonance spectroscopy and magnetisation transfer), including the thorough exploration of normal-appearing while matter, in OCB negative MS patients.
95%的多发性硬化症(MS)患者脑脊液(CSF)中存在局部产生的寡克隆IgG带(OCB)[2,3]。检测OCB最敏感的方法是等电聚焦(IEF)[1]。少数临床确诊为MS的患者缺乏鞘内IgG合成的证据[2,9]。本研究旨在比较脑脊液OCB阳性和阴性MS患者的脑磁共振成像(MRI)结果。该研究包括22例脑脊液OCB阴性且临床确诊为MS的患者以及22例年龄、病程、活动度和MS病程相匹配的OCB阳性对照。两组均使用扩展残疾状态量表(EDSS)评分进行临床评估。在西门子Magnetom(1.0T)上进行脑部T2加权MRI检查。对15个解剖学定义部位的病灶进行计数和测量大小:7个脑室周围(PV)区域和8个非脑室周围(NPV)区域。使用一个根据病灶大小加权的任意评分系统来估计总病灶负荷和区域病灶负荷:a)直径1 - 5mm的每个病灶计1分,b)直径6 - 10mm的一个病灶计2分,c)直径超过10mm的一个病灶计3分,融合病灶额外计1分[16]。萎缩情况评分如下:0 - 正常大小,1 - 轻度萎缩,2 - 中度萎缩,3 - 重度萎缩。脑脊液OCB阴性的MS患者脑MRI总负荷平均评分低于OCB阳性的MS患者(44对50),但差异无统计学意义。与脑脊液OCB阴性患者相比,OCB阳性MS组的脑室周围(32对23)、非脑室周围(26对19)和幕下(11对9)平均评分更高,但无统计学意义(图1)。脑脊液OCB阴性的MS患者中,EDSS评分与MRI总病灶负荷之间无相关性,而在OCB阳性组中,我们检测到EDSS评分与MRI总病灶负荷之间存在显著相关性(p = 0.026)(图2)。本研究结果表明,使用传统脑MRI时,脑脊液OCB阴性和阳性MS患者病理过程的范围和严重程度似乎相似。另一方面,我们发现脑脊液OCB阳性的MS患者中脑MRI总病灶负荷与EDSS之间存在统计学显著相关性,而在脑脊液OCB阴性的MS患者中未检测到这种相关性。脑脊液OCB阳性和阴性MS患者脑MRI结果的差异已被分析[9,12]。首先,泽曼等人报告脑脊液OCB阴性的MS患者与OCB阳性组相比,脑MRI总病灶负荷较低,但差异无统计学意义[9]。根据这些发现,深泽等人也未能显示脑脊液OCB阳性和阴性MS患者在脑MRI病灶的分布、范围、形状和数量上存在差异[12]。另一方面,已证明在MS患者中,如MRI所示,鞘内IgG合成速率显然与脑内斑块体积相关[17]。然而,我们的结果以及上述两项先前研究的结果均不支持这一观点。总之,脑脊液OCB阴性的MS患者MRI病灶负荷有降低趋势且与EDSS缺乏相关性,这值得使用新的MRI技术(磁共振波谱和磁化传递)进行进一步研究,包括对脑脊液OCB阴性的MS患者中外观正常的白质进行全面探索。