Clark Shannon, Tremblay François, Ste-Marie Diane
School of Human Kinetics, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Ottawa, Ont., Canada, K1H 8M5.
Neuropsychologia. 2004;42(1):105-12. doi: 10.1016/s0028-3932(03)00144-1.
In this study, we attempted to better delineate the changes in corticospinal excitability that accompany perceptual to motor transformations when people are asked to observe, image or imitate actions. Motor evoked potentials (MEP) from transcranial magnetic stimulation were recorded in the first dorsal interosseous (FDI) muscle of the dominant hand (15 right, 4 left) in five different conditions: (1) passive observation; (2) observation to imitate; (3) imagery; (4) imitation; and (5) counting backwards mentally. MEPs were also recorded at rest at the beginning and at the end of the session to establish baseline (BL) values. For the observation conditions, participants (n=19, 18-38 years) watched video sequences (5s) of hand actions performed by a model with the right arm (passive observation: scissors; observation to imitate: OK sign). Active imitation produced the greatest MEP facilitation compared to baseline, followed by the two observation conditions and the imagery conditions, which all produced similar levels of facilitation (post hoc comparisons). Mental counting produced some facilitation, but this effect was inconsistent. Baseline MEPs remained stable at the end of the session. A further comparison between right-handers (n=15) and left-handers (n=4) revealed no difference in the pattern of modulation across conditions. The similarity found between observation and imagery of hand actions in terms of corticospinal facilitation is interpreted in the light of the motor-simulation theory of Jeannerod [Neuroimage 14 (2001)], which proposes that perceiving actions involves neural simulation of the same action by the observer, thereby explaining the parallel between actions observed and actions imaged at the representational level.
在本研究中,我们试图更清晰地描绘当人们被要求观察、想象或模仿动作时,伴随从感知到运动转换的皮质脊髓兴奋性变化。在五种不同条件下,记录优势手(15名右利手、4名左利手)第一背侧骨间肌(FDI)的经颅磁刺激运动诱发电位(MEP):(1)被动观察;(2)观察后模仿;(3)想象;(4)模仿;(5)心算倒数。在实验开始和结束时的静息状态下也记录MEP,以确定基线(BL)值。对于观察条件,参与者(n = 19,18 - 38岁)观看模型用右臂执行手部动作的视频序列(5秒)(被动观察:剪刀动作;观察后模仿:OK手势)。与基线相比,主动模仿产生的MEP易化作用最大,其次是两种观察条件和想象条件,它们产生的易化水平相似(事后比较)。心算产生了一定的易化作用,但这种效应并不一致。实验结束时基线MEP保持稳定。右利手(n = 15)和左利手(n = 4)之间的进一步比较显示,不同条件下的调制模式没有差异。根据让纳罗德的运动模拟理论[《神经影像学》14(2001)]来解释在皮质脊髓易化方面手部动作观察和想象之间的相似性,该理论提出,感知动作涉及观察者对同一动作的神经模拟,从而在表征层面解释了观察到的动作和想象的动作之间的平行关系。