Fong G C Y, Mak Y F, Swartz B E, Walsh G O, Delgado-Escueta A V
California Comprehensive Epilepsy Program, UCLA, Los Angles, CA, USA.
Seizure. 2003 Dec;12(8):606-12. doi: 10.1016/s1059-1311(03)00138-9.
Clinically differentiating between localisation related and generalised epilepsy is important because it carries significant implications for planning diagnostic management strategy. Asymmetry of body parts such as toes, popliteal crease levels, thumbs, cubital crease levels, and forehead and facial structures, are common in patients with localisation related epilepsy syndromes. We retrospectively studied 337 patients with seizure disorders. Body part asymmetry was routinely documented. Fifty-six were excluded because of non-epileptic seizures, pure psychiatric disorders, non-epileptic neurological disorders, brain tumours and strokes. The relationship between clinically detectable body asymmetry (BA) and the electro-anatomic characteristics of their epilepsy was explored. Body asymmetry was found in 88 out of 282 cases, in which 64 (73.5%) suffered from localisation related epilepsy. Among localisation related epilepsy, BA were found in 41.5% (n=64/154) of patients. In contrast, only 18.75% (n=24/128) of patients with generalised seizure disorders showed similar findings (P<0.0001). Among patients with partial onset seizures, lateralisation of BA was concordant with their seizure origin in 75.9% (n=41/54) and discordant in 24.1% (n=13/54). Investigation results of 10 partial epilepsy cases were non-lateralising at the time of study. Peak age of onset of concordant case was 0-5 years old while discordant group was 6-15 years old. We conclude that BA in patients with seizure disorder is a useful clue to diagnosis of localisation related seizure and may provide clues for lateralising seizure origin in partial onset seizures.
临床上区分定位相关型癫痫和全身性癫痫很重要,因为这对规划诊断管理策略具有重大意义。在定位相关型癫痫综合征患者中,身体部位不对称很常见,如脚趾、腘横纹水平、拇指、肘横纹水平以及额头和面部结构。我们回顾性研究了337例癫痫发作障碍患者。常规记录身体部位不对称情况。56例因非癫痫性发作、单纯精神障碍、非癫痫性神经系统疾病、脑肿瘤和中风被排除。探讨了临床上可检测到的身体不对称(BA)与其癫痫的电解剖特征之间的关系。282例病例中有88例发现身体不对称,其中64例(73.5%)患有定位相关型癫痫。在定位相关型癫痫中,41.5%(n = 64/154)的患者存在BA。相比之下,全身性癫痫发作障碍患者中只有18.75%(n = 24/128)有类似发现(P<0.0001)。在部分性发作患者中,BA的定位与癫痫发作起源一致的占75.9%(n = 41/54),不一致的占24.1%(n = 13/54)。10例部分性癫痫病例在研究时的检查结果无定位倾向。一致组的发病高峰年龄为0 - 5岁,不一致组为6 - 15岁。我们得出结论,癫痫发作障碍患者的BA是诊断定位相关型发作的有用线索,可能为部分性发作的癫痫发作起源定位提供线索。