Lori Nicolas F, Conturo Thomas E, Le Bihan Denis
Mallinckrodt Institute of Radiology, Washington University School of Medicine, 4525 Scott Ave, St. Louis, MO 63110, USA.
J Magn Reson. 2003 Dec;165(2):185-95. doi: 10.1016/j.jmr.2003.08.011.
In q-space diffusion NMR, the probability P(r,td) of a molecule having a displacement r in a diffusion time td is obtained under the assumption that the diffusion-encoding gradient g has an infinitesimal duration. However, this assumption may not always hold, particularly in human MRI where the diffusion-encoding gradient duration delta is typically of the same order of magnitude as the time offset Delta between encoding gradients. In this case, finite-delta effects complicate the interpretation of displacement probabilities measured in q-space MRI, and the form by which the signal intensity relates to them. By considering the displacement-specific dephasing, <r/eiphi>, of a set of spins accumulating a constant displacement vector r in the total time Delta+delta during which diffusion is encoded, the probability recovered by a finite-delta q-space experiment can be interpreted. It is shown theoretically that a data analysis using a modified q-space index q=gammadeltaetag, with gamma the gyromagnetic ratio and eta=square root (Delta-delta/3)/(Delta+delta), recovers the correct displacement probability distribution if diffusion is multi-Gaussian free diffusion. With this analysis, we show that the displacement distribution P(r,texp) is measured at the experimental diffusion-encoding time texp=Delta+delta, and not at the reduced diffusion time tr=Delta-delta/3 as is generally assumed in the NMR and MRI literature. It is also shown that, by defining a probability P(y,Delta) that a time t<delta exists such that a displacement y occurs from time t to t+Delta, it is possible to describe the physical significance of the result obtained when we use the q-space formalism valid for infinitesimal delta when delta is not infinitesimal. These deductions were confirmed by simulations for homogeneous Gaussian diffusion and for heterogeneous diffusion in permeable microscopic Gaussian domains that are homogeneous on the microm scale. The results also hold for diffusion inside restricted spherical reflecting domains, but only if the radius of the domain is larger than a critical size. The simulations of the displacement-specific dephasing obtain that if delta>deltac then eta is not equal to square root (Delta-delta/3)/(Delta+delta) which implies that we can no longer obtain the correct displacement probability from the displacement distribution. In the case that /g/=18 mT/m and Delta-delta=5 ms, the parameter deltac in ms is given by "deltac=0.49a2+0.24" where a is the sphere's radius expressed in microm. Simulation of q-space restricted diffusion MRI experiments indicate that if eta=square root (Delta-delta/3)/(Delta+delta), the recovered displacement probability is always better than the Gaussian approximation, and the measured diffusion coefficient matches the diffusion coefficient at time texp=Delta+delta better than it matches the diffusion coefficient at time tr=Delta-delta/3. These results indicate that q-space MRI measurements of displacement probability distributions are theoretically possible in biological tissues using finite-duration diffusion-encoding gradients provided certain compartment size and diffusion encoding gradient duration constraints are met.
在q空间扩散核磁共振中,假设扩散编码梯度g的持续时间无穷小,可得到分子在扩散时间td内位移为r的概率P(r,td)。然而,这一假设并非总是成立,尤其是在人体磁共振成像中,扩散编码梯度持续时间δ通常与编码梯度之间的时间偏移量Δ处于同一数量级。在这种情况下,有限δ效应使q空间磁共振成像中测量的位移概率及其与信号强度的关系形式的解释变得复杂。通过考虑在总时间Δ+δ(在此期间进行扩散编码)内积累恒定位移矢量r的一组自旋的特定位移去相位<r/eiphi>,可以解释有限δ q空间实验恢复的概率。从理论上表明,如果扩散是多高斯自由扩散,使用修正的q空间指数q = γδetag(其中γ为旋磁比,η = √[(Δ - δ/3)/(Δ + δ)])进行数据分析,可恢复正确的位移概率分布。通过这种分析,我们表明位移分布P(r,texp)是在实验扩散编码时间texp = Δ+δ时测量的,而不是如核磁共振和磁共振成像文献中通常假设的在缩减扩散时间tr = Δ - δ/3时测量的。还表明,通过定义一个时间t < δ存在的概率P(y,Δ),使得从时间t到t + Δ发生位移y,就可以描述当δ不是无穷小时使用适用于无穷小δ的q空间形式主义所得到结果的物理意义。这些推导通过对均匀高斯扩散以及在微观尺度上均匀的可渗透微观高斯域中的非均匀扩散的模拟得到了证实。这些结果也适用于受限球形反射域内的扩散,但前提是域的半径大于临界尺寸。特定位移去相位的模拟结果表明,如果δ>δc,则η不等于√[(Δ - δ/3)/(Δ + δ)],这意味着我们不能再从位移分布中获得正确的位移概率。在/g/ = 18 mT/m且Δ - δ = 5 ms的情况下,以毫秒为单位的参数δc由“δc = 0.49a² + 0.24”给出,其中a是以微米为单位表示的球体半径。q空间受限扩散磁共振成像实验的模拟表明,如果η = √[(Δ - δ/3)/(Δ + δ)],恢复的位移概率总是优于高斯近似,并且测量的扩散系数与texp = Δ+δ时的扩散系数匹配得比与tr = Δ - δ/3时的扩散系数匹配得更好。这些结果表明,只要满足一定的隔室大小和扩散编码梯度持续时间约束,使用有限持续时间扩散编码梯度在生物组织中进行q空间磁共振成像测量位移概率分布在理论上是可行的。