Orth M, Snijders A H, Rothwell J C
Sobell Department of Motor Neuroscience and Movement Disorders, The National Hospital for Neurology and Neurosurgery, Institute of Neurology, Box 77, Royal Free and University College Medical School, Queen Square, London WC1N 3BG, UK.
Clin Neurophysiol. 2003 Dec;114(12):2362-9. doi: 10.1016/s1388-2457(03)00243-8.
To assess the variability of transcranial magnetic stimulation paired pulse measurements of cortical excitability between subjects, between sessions and within subjects within sessions.
In experiment 1, intracortical inhibition and facilitation were assessed with a fixed conditioning stimulus intensity (CSI) of 80% of active motor threshold (AMT) whereas in experiment 2, the effect of different CSIs (60-110% of AMT) was investigated.
Experiment 1 revealed that subjects differed significantly in the degree of inhibition and facilitation. Between sessions the variability was substantial as predicted by high within session variability. Experiment 2 allowed determination of individual thresholds for inhibition and facilitation. These thresholds were the best predictor of the amount of inhibition or facilitation at a given CSI. Across subjects we observed a high correlation of the threshold for inhibition (expressed in terms of maximum stimulator output) with AMT (r=0.93). Results for facilitation were more variable.
The variability was high if a single CSI was used to compare the percent intracortical inhibition or facilitation between subjects, or between sessions. Much less variable was the threshold for intracortical inhibition/facilitation, which was highly correlated to AMT. We suggest that the ratio of CSI:AMT is a robust and useful additional measure of the integrity of neuronal circuits underlying intracortical inhibition/facilitation.
评估经颅磁刺激配对脉冲测量皮质兴奋性在不同受试者之间、不同测试时段之间以及同一受试者在各测试时段内的变异性。
在实验1中,采用固定的条件刺激强度(CSI)为主动运动阈值(AMT)的80%来评估皮质内抑制和易化,而在实验2中,研究了不同CSI(AMT的60 - 110%)的效果。
实验1显示,受试者在抑制和易化程度上存在显著差异。正如测试时段内的高变异性所预测的那样,不同测试时段之间的变异性很大。实验2确定了抑制和易化的个体阈值。这些阈值是给定CSI下抑制或易化量的最佳预测指标。在所有受试者中,我们观察到抑制阈值(以最大刺激器输出表示)与AMT高度相关(r = 0.93)。易化的结果变异性更大。
如果使用单一的CSI来比较不同受试者之间或不同测试时段之间的皮质内抑制或易化百分比,变异性会很高。皮质内抑制/易化的阈值变异性小得多,且与AMT高度相关。我们认为,CSI:AMT的比值是皮质内抑制/易化基础神经元回路完整性的一种可靠且有用的额外测量指标。