Kekkaku. 2003 Nov;78(11):717-22.
Recent development of tuberculosis in Japan tends to converge on a specific high risk group. The proportion of tuberculosis developing particularly from the compromised hosts in the high risk group is especially high. At this symposium, therefore, we took up diabetes mellitus, gastrectomy, dialysis, AIDS and the elderly for discussion. Many new findings and useful reports for practical medical treatment are submitted; why these compromised hosts are predisposed to tuberculosis, tuberculosis diagnostic and remedial notes of those compromised hosts etc. It is an important question for the future to study how to prevent tuberculosis from these compromised hosts. 1. Tuberculosis in diabetes mellitus: aggravation and its immunological mechanism: Kazuyoshi KAWAKAMI (Department of Internal Medicine, Division of Infectious Diseases, Graduate School and Faculty of Medicine, University of the Ryukyus). It has been well documented that diabetes mellitus (DM) is a major aggravating factor in tuberculosis. The onset of this disease is more frequent in DM patients than in individuals with any underlying diseases. However, the precise mechanism of this finding remains to be fully understood. Earlier studies reported that the migration, phagocytosis and bactericidal activity of neutrophils are all impaired in DM patients, which is related to their reduced host defense to infection with extracellular bacteria, such as S. aureus and E. colli. Host defense to mycobacterial infection is largely mediated by cellular immunity, and Th1-related cytokines, such as IFN-gamma and IL-12, play a central role in this response. It is reported that serum level of these cytokines and their production by peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) are reduced in tuberculosis patients with DM, and this is supposed to be involved in the high incidence of tuberculosis in DM. Our study observed similar findings and furthermore indicated that IFN-gamma and IL-12 production by BCG-stimulated PBMC was lower in poorly-controlled DM patients than that in well-controlled DM patients and healthy subjects. Thus, these clinical data suggest that the high incidence of tuberculosis in DM patients is due to the impaired production of Th1-related cytokines. However, direct evidences to prove this possibility remain to be obtained. In 1980, Saiki and co-workers reported that host defense and delayed-type hypersensitivity response to M. tuberculosis was hampered in a mouse DM model established by injecting streptozotocin (Infect Immun. 1980; 28: 127-131). We followed their investigation with the similar observations. Interestingly, levels of IFN-gamma and IL-12 in serum, lung, liver and spleen after infection were significantly reduced in DM mice when compared with those in control mice. Considered collectively, these results strongly suggest that the reduced production of Th1-related cytokines leads to the susceptibility of DM to mycobacterial infection. However, it remains to be understood how DM hampers the synthesis of Th1-related cytokines. In our preliminary study, the production of these cytokines by PBMC from DM patients and healthy subjects was not affected under a high glucose condition. Thus, it is not likely that the increased level of glucose directly suppresses the cell-mediated immune responses. Further investigations are needed to make these points clear. 2. A study of gastrectomy cases in pulmonary tuberculosis patients: Takenori YAGI (Division of Thoracic Disease, National Chiba-Higashi Hospital). Patients who have undergone gastric resection are considered at increased risk of developing pulmonary tuberculosis. I have investigated the role played by gastrectomy in giving rise to pulmonary tuberculosis. Of 654 pulmonary tuberculosis patients admitted to National Chiba-Higashi Hospital from January 1999 to December 2001, 55 patients (31-84 years old, mean 63.5 +/- 12.5 years, 48 males and 7 females) had the history of gastric resection. The incidence of gastrectomy among patients with pulmonary tuberculosis was 8.4 percent. The mean age of gastric resection was 50.2 +/- 16.6 years, and the mean interval from gastrectomy to pulmonary tuberculosis was 13.6 +/- 11.0 years. On admission to our hospital, 34 out of 55 cases were smear positive by sputum examination for acid-fast bacilli and 39 cases had cavitary lesions on chest X-ray. Gastrectomy was done due to carcinoma of the stomach in 31 cases, gastric and/or duodenal ulcer in 21 cases, adenomatous polyp in two cases, and accidental injury in one case. 52 patients improved, but three cases died due to pulmonary tuberculosis. No one had recurrence of carcinoma of the stomach. Body weight, Body Mass Index, Prognostic Nutritional Index (PNI; 10x serum albumin concentration +0.005 x peripheral lymphocyte count) which was proposed by Onodera, serum albumin level and serum total cholesterol level were lower in the gastrectomy group than in the non-gastrectomy group. I calculated the odds of tuberculosis among gastrectomy patients to be 3.8 times that of appropriate controls. This study confirms that gastrectomy is one of the risk factor(s) of tuberculosis. However, whether gastrectomy in itself is a risk factor or whether it is secondarily associated with another risk factor such as underweight status and/or inadequate nutrition following surgery remains unclear. 3. Immunodefficiency and tuberculosis in dialysis patients: Hajime INAMOTO (Division of Dialysis, Keio University School of Medicine). The patients who have renal insufficiency is fatal, but they can live much longer by dialysis. The number of lymphocytes of the patients whose serum creatinine was 10 mg/dl or more has decreased to about 50% of the people who have normal kidney. When the lymphocyte was cultured after it was stimulated with PHA, the DNA synthesis of the patients' lymphocyte was much lower than that of the modest people's. In the dialysis food, the nutrient such as vitamins, minerals, etc. were lacked. The density of the serum albumin of the dialysis patient has decreased. Many of them were thin when their BMI was examined. The size of the patients' erythema by the tuberculin test has become small. There were many patients receiving dialysis with erythema but no induration. It means that the delayed skin reaction specific to Mycobacterium tuberculosis has decreased among the dialysis patients. The morbidity rate, the mortality rate and the prevalence of tuberculosis was much higher than the general population. The anamnesis of tuberculosis was also high. Most of those tuberculosis patients appear the disease from the period immediately before the beginning of dialysis to one year after that. That is also the period that patients' number of peripheral blood lymphocyte decreased and the tuberculin reaction positivity rate fell sharply. During the dialysis patients, pulmonary tuberculosis with cavities was minority and extrapulmonary tuberculosis and miliary tuberculosis were remarkably many. People with large reaction against the tuberculin test were better prognosis than those with smaller reaction. It was thought that anorexia, weakening, and a weight decrease were seen when the immunity decreased. At the end stage of renal failure, kidney shrink, vitamin D activation becomes difficult, and the low calcium blood syndrome appears. The calcification of tuberculoma is absorbed, soft tuberculoma becomes baring, the caseation abscess melts, and the endogenous infection occurs. The cell immunity has decreased, and tuberculosis attacks. It might be such circumstances that tuberculosis happen frequently at the dialysis introduction period. There are a lot of cases that the caseation necrosis is a little, and the formation of tuberculoma is bad in the pathology opinion. Due to the decrease in the cell immunity, cavities are not formed easily. It is easy to stay in the leaching lesion so that anti-tuberculosis drugs are much effective, and the patients recover easily. However, if the treatment is delayed, it is fatally because hematogenous metastasis are easy to occur and become miliary tuberculosis. 4. AIDS and tuberculosis: Hideaki NAGAI (Department of Respiratory Diseases, National Tokyo Hospital). With AIDS patients with tuberculosis, there are the following problems on the treatment. (1) The adverse reactions by antituberculosis drugs tend to occur in AIDS patients. Eleven of 33 AIDS patients with tuberculosis had the adverse reactions (skin rash, fever, liver dysfunction) considered to be due to antituberculosis drugs. It is a very large burden for the HIV infected persons to take simultaneously antituberculosis drugs, medicines for opportunistic infections, and anti-HIV medicines. Since many medicines are taken, it is difficult to determine which drug is the cause once an adverse reaction occurs and all medicines should be often stopped. (2) The combined use with rifampicin (RFP) is difficult for the protease inhibitors and nonnuclear acid reverse transcriptase inhibitors. RFP induces cytochrome P-450 in liver, accelerates the metabolism of some concomitant drug agents, and reduces blood concentration them remarkably. When starting the two above-mentioned medicines during tuberculosis treatment, RFP should be changed to rifabutin (RFB) which has less induction of P-450 than RFP. However, some procedures are required for acquisition of RFB and it is a little complicated in Japan. CDC mentioned the combined use with RFP and efavirenz (EFV) is possible. So, the treatment with EFV and RFP is recently chosen. However, the monitor of the blood concentration of EFV is required, and the dose of EFV should be increased if it is a low value. (3) When a highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART) is given to AIDS patients with tuberculosis, transient worsening of tuberculosis may develop after about two weeks. (ABSTRACT TRUNCATED)
日本近期结核病的发展趋势倾向于集中在特定的高风险群体。尤其是高危人群中,特别是来自免疫功能受损宿主的结核病发病比例特别高。因此,在本次研讨会上,我们选取了糖尿病、胃切除术、透析、艾滋病和老年人进行讨论。会上提交了许多新的研究发现以及对实际医疗有帮助的报告,包括这些免疫功能受损宿主易患结核病的原因、针对这些宿主的结核病诊断和治疗注意事项等。未来,研究如何预防这些免疫功能受损宿主感染结核病是一个重要问题。1. 糖尿病患者的结核病:病情加重及其免疫机制:川上和义(琉球大学医学部研究生院及医学部内科传染病科)。糖尿病(DM)是结核病的一个主要加重因素,这一点已有充分记录。DM患者中该疾病的发病率比任何其他基础疾病患者都更高。然而,这一发现的确切机制仍有待充分了解。早期研究报告称,DM患者中性粒细胞的迁移、吞噬和杀菌活性均受损,这与他们对金黄色葡萄球菌和大肠杆菌等细胞外细菌感染的宿主防御能力降低有关。宿主对分枝杆菌感染的防御主要由细胞免疫介导,Th1相关细胞因子,如干扰素-γ(IFN-γ)和白细胞介素-12(IL-12)在这一反应中起核心作用。据报道,合并DM的结核病患者血清中这些细胞因子水平及其在外周血单个核细胞(PBMC)中的产生均降低,这被认为与DM患者中结核病的高发病率有关。我们的研究观察到了类似的结果,并且进一步表明,与血糖控制良好的DM患者和健康受试者相比,血糖控制不佳的DM患者经卡介苗刺激的PBMC产生的IFN-γ和IL-12更低。因此,这些临床数据表明,DM患者中结核病的高发病率是由于Th1相关细胞因子产生受损。然而,仍有待获得直接证据来证明这一可能性。1980年,Saiki及其同事报告称,通过注射链脲佐菌素建立的小鼠DM模型中,宿主对结核分枝杆菌的防御和迟发型超敏反应受到阻碍(《感染与免疫》,1980年;28: 127 - 131)。我们在类似观察中沿用了他们的研究方法。有趣的是,与对照小鼠相比,感染后DM小鼠血清、肺、肝和脾中的IFN-γ和IL-12水平显著降低。综合考虑,这些结果强烈表明,Th1相关细胞因子产生减少导致DM患者易患分枝杆菌感染。然而,DM如何阻碍Th1相关细胞因子的合成仍有待了解。在我们的初步研究中,高糖条件下DM患者和健康受试者PBMC产生这些细胞因子的情况并未受到影响。因此,血糖水平升高不太可能直接抑制细胞介导的免疫反应。需要进一步研究来明确这些问题。2. 肺结核患者胃切除术病例研究:八木武纪(千叶东医院胸病科)。接受过胃切除术的患者被认为患肺结核的风险增加。我研究了胃切除术在引发肺结核方面所起的作用。在1999年1月至2001年12月入住千叶东医院的654例肺结核患者中,有55例(年龄31 - 84岁,平均63.5±12.5岁,男性48例,女性7例)有胃切除术史。肺结核患者中胃切除术的发生率为8.4%。胃切除术的平均年龄为50.2±16.6岁,从胃切除术到患肺结核的平均间隔时间为13.6±11.0年。我院收治时,55例患者中有34例痰涂片抗酸杆菌阳性,39例胸部X线有空洞性病变。胃切除术的原因包括胃癌31例、胃和/或十二指肠溃疡21例、腺瘤性息肉2例、意外伤害1例。52例患者病情好转,但3例因肺结核死亡。无1例胃癌复发。胃切除术组的体重、体重指数、小野寺提出的预后营养指数(PNI;10×血清白蛋白浓度 + 0.005×外周淋巴细胞计数)、血清白蛋白水平和血清总胆固醇水平均低于非胃切除术组。我计算出胃切除术患者患结核病的几率是适当对照组的3.8倍。本研究证实胃切除术是结核病的风险因素之一。然而,胃切除术本身是否是一个风险因素,或者它是否继发于另一个风险因素,如体重过轻状态和/或手术后营养不足,仍不清楚。3. 透析患者的免疫缺陷与结核病:稻本肇(庆应义塾大学医学院透析科)。肾功能不全的患者病情危急,但通过透析他们可以存活更长时间。血清肌酐为10mg/dl或更高的患者淋巴细胞数量已降至正常肾脏者的约50%。当淋巴细胞用PHA刺激后进行培养时,患者淋巴细胞的DNA合成比正常人低得多。透析饮食中缺乏维生素、矿物质等营养素。透析患者血清白蛋白密度降低。检查他们的BMI时,许多患者体重偏轻。透析患者结核菌素试验的红斑大小变小。有许多接受透析的患者有红斑但无硬结。这意味着透析患者中针对结核分枝杆菌的迟发性皮肤反应减弱。结核病的发病率、死亡率和患病率远高于普通人群。结核病既往史也很高。这些结核病患者大多在透析开始前至开始后一年内发病。这也是患者外周血淋巴细胞数量减少、结核菌素反应阳性率急剧下降的时期。透析患者中,有空洞的肺结核较少,肺外结核和粟粒性结核明显较多。结核菌素试验反应大者预后优于反应小者。人们认为免疫力下降时会出现食欲不振、身体虚弱和体重减轻。在肾衰竭末期,肾脏萎缩,维生素D活化困难,出现低钙血症。结核瘤的钙化被吸收,软结核瘤暴露,干酪样脓肿溶解,发生内源性感染。细胞免疫下降,结核病发作。可能就是在透析开始阶段经常发生这种情况。从病理学角度看,有很多病例干酪样坏死较少,结核瘤形成不良。由于细胞免疫下降,不容易形成空洞。容易停留在渗出性病变中,因此抗结核药物非常有效,患者容易康复。然而,如果治疗延迟,就会致命,因为容易发生血行转移并发展为粟粒性结核。4. 艾滋病与结核病:永井秀明(东京国立医院呼吸疾病科)。对于合并结核病的艾滋病患者,治疗存在以下问题。(1)抗结核药物的不良反应在艾滋病患者中更容易发生。33例合并结核病的艾滋病患者中有11例出现了被认为是由抗结核药物引起的不良反应(皮疹、发热、肝功能障碍)。同时服用抗结核药物、机会性感染药物和抗HIV药物对HIV感染者来说是非常大的负担。由于服用多种药物,一旦发生不良反应,很难确定是哪种药物导致的,所有药物通常都要停用。(2)蛋白酶抑制剂和非核苷类逆转录酶抑制剂难以与利福平(RFP)联合使用。RFP诱导肝脏中的细胞色素P - 450,加速一些伴随药物的代谢,并显著降低它们的血药浓度。在结核病治疗期间开始使用上述两种药物时,RFP应改为利福布汀(RFB),其对P - 450的诱导作用比利福平小。然而,在日本获取RFB需要一些程序,而且有点复杂。美国疾病控制与预防中心提到RFP与依非韦伦(EFV)可以联合使用。因此,最近选择了EFV和RFP联合治疗。然而,需要监测EFV的血药浓度,如果值低,应增加EFV的剂量。(3)对合并结核病的艾滋病患者给予高效抗逆转录病毒治疗(HAART)时,大约两周后结核病可能会出现短暂恶化。(摘要截断)